StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Court Case related to the topic Sexual Harrasment at Workplace - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The case identified some of the circumstances in which employers could be held responsible under Title VII of the Civil Rights Acts of 1964. The…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.4% of users find it useful
Court Case related to the topic Sexual Harrasment at Workplace
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Court Case related to the topic Sexual Harrasment at Workplace"

Sexual Harassment at Workplace College: Sexual Harassment at Workplace Faragher against the of Boca Raton was a case that was handled by the Supreme Court of the United States in the year 1998. The case identified some of the circumstances in which employers could be held responsible under Title VII of the Civil Rights Acts of 1964. The employer could be held liable following the actions and suggestions of supervisory employee that has caused sexual intimidation to his subordinates. Thus, resulting in an unfriendly working environment that is equivalent to employment discrimination.

In this particular case, the petitioner, Beth Ann Faragher was a lifeguard, but had resigned from her position. She had worked as a part-time lifeguard for the Marine Safety Section (Buchanan & Wiswall, 2009). During her tenure, her immediate supervisors were Bill Terry, David Silverman, and Robert Gordon. After her resignation in 1990, she took an action against Terry, Silverman, and the City. Faragher complained that both Terry and Silverman had repeatedly created a sexually unfriendly environment while at the beach.

Also, she alleged that the duo had subjected fellow female lifeguards to offensive and uninvited touch by the use of prurient remarks and by speaking of women in decadent ways. The complainant said that at some point, Terry had vowed never to give a promotion to any woman. On the other hand, Faragher specified that at one point, Silverman asked her to date him and failure to which he would make her clean the lavatories for a whole year. Pointing out that both Terry and Silverman were agents of the City and that their conduct resulted in discrimination in their conditions, privileges, and terms given by the employment, the complainant sought judgment against the City.

Initially, Faragher had not complained to the higher management about both Terry and Silverman. At first, she reported the matter to Gordon, who was the training captain and was working with Silverman. However, Gordon reported the matter to his supervisor, Terry and afterward took no action since he felt that the City could not be concerned about such issues. Faragher’s bench trial realized that two months before her resignation, a former lifeguard had written to the City’s Personnel Director, with complaints of harassment she had faced from Terry and Silverman.

After the complaints, the City concluded that the duo had misbehaved and were therefore reprimanded. They were required to choose between facing a suspension without pay and forfeiting their annual leave. From these findings, the District Court that was dealing with Faragher’s case concluded that Terry and Silverman’s conduct was discriminatory in nature (Buchanan & Wiswall, 2009). Also, the court ruled that the harassment was enough to alter Faragher’s conditions for employment. Besides, their conduct constituted an abusive working environment where Faragher could not fit.

In addition, the District Court ruled that it had three justifications that it held the City liable for the harassment of its supervisory workers. The first one was that the court noted that the harassment was pervasive enough, and it could support a deduction that the City had a hint on the issue. Second, the Court ruled that the City was liable following the traditional agency principles. The reason for the second ruling was that both Terry and Silverman were acting as the City’s agent when they committed the acts.

Lastly, the Court made the observation that the knowledge that Gordon had concerning the harassment together with his actions gave an incredible basis for the placing liability on the City. Resultantly, the District Court awarded the complainant a dollar as the nominal damages on her Title VII claim. ReferencesBuchanan, P., & Wiswall, C. W. (2009). Evolving Understanding of Workplace Harassment and Employer Liability: Implications of Recent Supreme Court Decisions under Title VII, The. Wake Forest L. Rev., 34, 55.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Court Case related to the topic Sexual Harrasment at Workplace Essay”, n.d.)
Court Case related to the topic Sexual Harrasment at Workplace Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1696404-court-case-related-to-the-topic-sexual-harrasment-at-workplace
(Court Case Related to the Topic Sexual Harrasment at Workplace Essay)
Court Case Related to the Topic Sexual Harrasment at Workplace Essay. https://studentshare.org/business/1696404-court-case-related-to-the-topic-sexual-harrasment-at-workplace.
“Court Case Related to the Topic Sexual Harrasment at Workplace Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1696404-court-case-related-to-the-topic-sexual-harrasment-at-workplace.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Court Case related to the topic Sexual Harrasment at Workplace

Harassment at Work

hellip; The given website is definitely a rich source for the legal information and data pertaining to the issues related to the gender and sex discrimination at work.... This website also provides legal information and data associated with many other cases that are very similar to the Collins case. The plaintiff, Alisha alleged that her employer discriminated against her on the basis of her sex, by failing to restore her to her position, after she took a leave owing to complications with her pregnancy....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Male Sexual Harassment Claims on the Rise in Mid Sized Corporation

This paper 'Male sexual Harassment Claims on the Rise in Mid Sized Corporation" focuses on the fact that it would be better to settle the case with Mr.... Larry to take the case to the court and would also ruin the reputation of the company.... It would be ethical to settle the case with Mr.... Larry by paying him a certain amount of money as that would be less expensive than going to the court which would cost the company a lot....
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

Religion in the Workplace

The author of the paper examines the case of religious discrimination at the workplace and states that every employee has the right to observe their faithful practices which may include but are not limited to the style of dress, praying, and fasting.... meant to harass or intimidate an employee on the basis of religion” to avoid legal actions as well as to promote harmony within the workplace (FindLaw, n....
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

Workplace Risk

s a result, he suffered from an injury that was elevation related while acting as a counterweight pulley to descend an 800 pound reel down stairs.... RUNNER, Respondent, v NEW YORK STOCK EXCHANGE, case no 197 Victorwho is the plaintiff of the above case was directed to move an 800 pounded wire with several other workers down stairs.... The plaintiffs' injury was as a result of a direct consequence of the reel going downstairs as if he was positioned in the reel's path (Victor Vs New York Exchange, case no 197)....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Mitsubishi believes in EEO Now

The case sexual and racial discrimination are some of the central concerns that organizations have to confront.... The case of sexual and racial discrimination evidenced at Mitsubishi was certainly a low ground for the organization.... The decision reached to settle the sexual harassment lawsuit is a positive connotation on the commitment of the organization toward addressing its core concerns.... In any case, it occurs that the company instituted several changes in the American division after the occurrence of these disheartening events....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

The Workings of the Multinational Organization

This would mean that multinationals have to invest in not only a change in strategy over a period of time but also carry out related activities like proper methods of hiring, removing inefficient employees, investing a little more on the units which are ready to default as well as strengthen the cash cow strategic unit of the company, all the same....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Harassment at Workplace on the Ground of Sexual Orientation as a Problem of Lionel

From the paper "Harassment at workplace on the Ground of Sexual Orientation as a Problem of Lionel" it is clear that the conditions at the workplace for an employee have worsened to such limits that the employee can not continue to work there.... In the event of a contravention, in relation to any premises to which this Act applies, of any such provisions of this Act as are mentioned in subsection (2) of this section or of regulations made under any such provisions, then—  (a) except in a case falling within either of the two following paragraphs, the occupier of the premises shall be guilty of an offence; as also for negligence in torts at common law....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Why Did Lionel Take Legal Action against Estate Agents Firm

workplace harassment is a serious legal offence.... Lionel's sexual preference, as well as the manner of his dress, has become the constant source of irritable sniggering by his colleagues and Lionel is bothered his Line Manager is doing nothing to alleviate his agonies.... However, his sexual orientation, as well as his hurt attitude, has compounded his woes.... The crux of the issue is his sexual orientation.... To others in the office, Lionel is a sexual deviant....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us