StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Ethical Dilemmas of Korean Motors of North America - Case Study Example

Summary
"Ethical Dilemmas of Korean Motors of North America" paper examines the dilemma is whether or not to accept the adoption of a new sales model that will demand relaying of adverts full of falsehoods and exaggerations thereby presenting a misleading image to the consumers…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER99% of users find it useful
Ethical Dilemmas of Korean Motors of North America
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Ethical Dilemmas of Korean Motors of North America"

Module Executive Summary Ethical dilemmas require ethical considerations to solve. They are quite common but some dilemmas result from far-reaching ethical implications, and the case study presents one of such a kind. Being the vice-president of sales at Korean Motors of North America the decisions I make have extensive repercussions on the company. The dilemma here is whether or not to accept the adoption of a new sales model that will demand relaying of adverts full of falsehoods and exaggerations thereby presenting a misleading image to the consumers. I will not accept this move and have decided to refer my resentment to the home office back in Korea. Business Ethics Ethical dilemmas, especially for the top management, are common and as the US vice-president for sales at Korean Motors of North America such situations can present immense challenges. The company’s footprint in this market had for ten years progressed quite well and was turning considerable profit margins. This has been attributed to the vigorous advertising and double warranty offers as compared to competitors. The new proposal to drastically change focus from the low-cost model to young nouveau riche has come as a huge surprise. This is made worse by the fact that the advertisement campaign geared to the change is supposed to edge on deceiving customers by highly exaggerating the aspects of the cars. I totally do not agree with this approach and, therefore, am faced by a number of choices on the way forward. I can take the concerns to the home office in Korea, abide by the new sales model or simply leave the company and search for a new job. I will assess the options based on the various theories so as to arrive at a conclusion on what is the best course of action at this point. The utilitarian approach, as developed by Joan Stuart Mill, states that “actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness” according to Irwin (27). Happiness under this theory is regarded as the presence of pleasure with absence of pain while unhappiness is the reverse (Quinton 2). My dilemma emanates from the fact that I feel the decision to change the sales model will lead to my unhappiness and those of the consumers. The brand image is already stable with the low-cost model and lengthy warranties. This is what I am also, as the vice-president, known for in the market and have been preaching the model to every employee. Distracting this flow will definitely lead to loss of trust from the market and destabilize the current mission that was well entrenched in every employee’s mind. This theory can be helpful since it refers one to the welfare of self and that of others in terms of whether an action will derive happiness or unhappiness and, therefore, leading to a judgment that will be acceptable by the key stakeholders. Deontology, on the other hand, rests judgment of an action morality based on whether it followed laid down rules and procedures. In short, deontology finds an action moral if it followed laid rules and vice versa (Brook 436). The action, in this regard, is less important than its consequences. In my scenario, this theory is too plain to help in determining my next course of action. This is owing to the fact that by abiding by the new directives, I will be totally disregarding my moral obligation toward the company and the customers. It is this blind following of rules that am against and the basic cause of the current dilemma. As expressed earlier, the company will be bound to lose a wide customer base owing to this sudden change. The rules in this regard should remain unchanged. This theory can be helpful in case my task was to further strengthen the company’s brand based on the current strategy of low-cost marketplace as a target since it has already proved profitable. Ethical intuitionism is based more on moral beliefs and that one’s intuition should be aware, without inference, of moral truths. This is a more subjective viewpoint of issues that cause ethical or moral conflicts. This means that people innately harbor moral knowledge on issues which is not necessarily out of daily interactions or experiences. In respect to my case, I can comfortably say that, to a large extent, this innate knowledge of moral values plays a huge role in my opposition of the new sales model which is meant to sell success to the young nouveau riche. Personally, I do not entertain situations that clearly require one to deceive, give falsehoods and unnecessarily exaggerate claims simply to record sales. If the product is good enough, an extensive and rigorous marketing campaign will sell the product without giving falsehoods or illusions to customers (Lamb, Hair and McDaniel 219). Actually, if this approach is adopted, the chances of the company surviving this competitive U.S market will drastically reduce. It will take a year or two for customers to realize that these are the same products as before only that the marketing has changed to deceive and con them with high prices. The theory guides one to follow their intuition and thus, their inner judgment which is critical for those in top-management positions. Virtue ethics requires one to neither follow rules nor aim at deriving desirable consequences. Instead, the theory encourages one to deliver judgment on a dilemma based on character. It presses that one should concentrate on upholding virtuous characteristics (Otsuka 125). For example, honestly is a virtuous characteristic. This theory, which was advanced by Aristotle, however, requires these traits to be effortless out of them having been nurtured over time. One of the requirements of the new Ad campaign is to give falsehoods and unlimited exaggeration of facts to consumers. This is totally against virtue ethics to change the company’s branding supposedly to achieve a different competitive edge. Based on this, I would not go ahead to commission the new branding and must taken action to revert this trend for the sake of the company and the consumers. Virtue ethics is quite valuable in fostering ethical behaviors in any workplace since it considers the best course of action from a virtuous viewpoint. If anything goes wrong with me as the vice-president of sales, I will be held responsible for the results thereof. To a large extent, the new directives are also illegal in that they are clearly meant to deceive through blatant lies. Any resultant action will also cause harm to consumers (Martin 95). It is important to ask to whose benefit is it that the new model is adopted. Another question will be how sustainable would be the falsehoods and exaggerations. The decision to adopt the new strategy will be costly to my career, in the long term, since the company most likely will collapse. The change will be costly to implement and can result in total loss of trust in this very-promising U.S market and thus should be avoided at all cost. Having considered all the directing ethical theories, I have decided to take my concerns to the home office in Korea. From a utilitarian point of view, I am inclined to make the customers happy which results to happiness and growth in the organization. The company better sticks with the current mission, rules and procedures than adopt new ones that are far from ethical. Adopting the new rules will lead to company’s collapse and it would be better to resign if my fight to retain the current model fails. Ethical intuitionism directs me to only pursue the current low-cost marketplace model that is true to its Ad messages and matches product specifications. Virtue ethics requires me to exercise honesty for the good of all. My position will be misconstrued to mean I am rebellious or aversive to changes. However, this is a shallow perspective to consider bearing in mind the consequences that the decision holds with regard to the future of the company. I intend to present a convincing argument to the company’s high-level management in Korea within the shortest time possible aiming to block the changes that, if adopted, will cripple Korean Motors of North America. Works Cited Brook, R. “Deontology, Paradox, and Moral Evil,” Social Theory and Practice, 33.3 (2007): 431-40. Print. Irwin, T. The Development of Ethics: A Historical and Critical Study. Vol. 3, From Kant to Rawls. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009. Print. Lamb, Charles., Hair, Joe., and McDaniel, Carl. Essentials of Marketing. Cengage Learning, 2011. Print. Martin, Glenn. Human Values and Ethics in the Workplace. Lulu. 2011. Print. Otsuka, M. “Saving Lives, Moral Theories and the Claims of Individuals,” Philosophy and Public Affairs, 34.2 (2006): 109-135. Print. Quinton, A. Utilitarian Ethics. London: Duckworth, (2007): 2-3. Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethical Dilemmas of Korean Motors of North America

The Rise of the Mileage Programs: The Case of Korean Air Alliances

Redemption Rates of korean Airlines 24 CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION: The beginning of 2012 marked the modification of airlines.... Sky Team is an alliance that consists of korean Airline, Aeromexico, Aeroflot, Air Europa, Middle East Airlines and Kenya Airways.... Sky Team is an alliance that consists of korean Airline, Aeromexico, Aeroflot, Air Europa, Middle East Airlines and Kenya Airways....
26 Pages (6500 words) Dissertation

Dilemmas in Medical Professional Codes

This essay "dilemmas in Medical Professional Codes" focuses on a variety of professional principles that serve as standard parameters in ensuring the quality regulation of offered goods or services to the public consumers, including the standardized practice in the medical field.... as a patient ends and where the General Physician's obligation as medical professional begins; hence, an ethical dilemma is formed.... Bearing the illustrated changes in mind, there is a general assumption that concepts in medical ethical conduct are not absolute in every situation, including the core ethical principles that govern the medical practice....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Foreign Policy and the Protection the National Interest

However, in a world that has been influenced by many wars, conflicts, and catastrophic events from which hard lessons have been learnt, it has to be asked if foreign policies of nations ought to contain elements that attempt to promote useful ethical and moral values that are thought to be important for the progress of humanity.... After having lost millions of lives and having endured two World Wars, a broad consensus has now finally emerged regarding what may be considered to be ethical behavior by a state and international institutions do exist to protect and promote international law (Dongyan, 2006, Sections I to IV) and (Harries, 2005, Pp....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Concepts of non-violence in response to 9/11: European options to influence US policy

The end of the Cold War and the events of 9/11 have provided a catalyst for unprecedented challenges to the international order and national security policy.... Arguably the most important challenge has been the appropriate and most efficacious method to combat a transient and.... ... ... ngible enemy, which transcends borders and the conventional notion of an organised army “yet has shown a remarkable resilience against traditional military firepower” (Mahmood, 2008 at www....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

Cultural Diversities in the Graying Population of the Caucasian American and Asian American Races

The United States of america is home to all races, religion, and cultures.... The Caucasian Americans, also called European Americans, or White Americans, are the largest but slowest growing group with the lowest poverty rate ('United States of america: Poverty and Wealth,' 2010), which began arriving after the Revolutionary War in the 1800s....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Controversial Dilemmas of MNCs in Emerging Market Economies

The thesis "Controversial dilemmas of MNCs in Emerging Market Economies" focuses on the critical analysis of the controversial dilemmas that multinational companies (MNCs) face in the emerging market economies when they simultaneously focus on economic growth and social responsibility.... For acquiring vigorous market goodwill and for remaining in the market (in the local as well as global market) as a dominant player they have to take into consideration the ethical aspects of society and environment as a simultaneous mechanism with growth and development strategies of business and they have to become good corporate citizens....
21 Pages (5250 words) Thesis

Kim Jong II and His Leadership

His ruthlessness, calculating nature, and the unwillingness to compromise with other nations are traits that do not work in north Korea's favor since they create the impression of a dictatorial state that is not amenable to diplomacy and therefore cooperation with the world comity of nations.... As a result, north Korea has been prepared to allow some concessions to the United States in return for the favors received from that country when Clinton was the President in the form of humanitarian assistance and condolence s upon the death of his father....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Marketing Planning Issues for Samsung Mobile

Samsung is a South korean Chaebol and it does operate as a korean company from within.... A paper 'Marketing Planning Issues for Samsung Mobile' states that a marketing order is an order to buy or to sell a stock or security at the best available price in the market or industry (Tim, 2014)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us