StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

(Spanking, a Necessary Evil - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
This work "Spanking, a Necessary Evi" describes the ‘spanking culture’, the influence of punishment on children's behavior. The author outlines discipline techniques, the children's rights. From this work, it is clear that such kind of punishment can cause a lot of problems in the future. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
(Spanking, a Necessary Evil
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "(Spanking, a Necessary Evil"

Spanking, a Necessary Evil Spanking or striking children as a method to correct bad behaviour has beenwidely used by parents in many cultures as a primary means of discipline, particularly among younger children. Lately, though, this disciplinary technique has been the subject of criticism among experts who have adopted a philosophy of ‘positive parenting’ even as the possibility of spanking or striking has been removed from the school’s arsenal of possible punishment techniques. Corporal punishment seems a simple and effective way to punish children when they stray from desired actions. Children seem to respond much quicker to physical punishments or even the threat of this than they do verbal corrections. Many parents believe that spanking is an acceptable form of punishment and consider the practice as an indispensable component of child-rearing. Others believe hitting anyone is wrong including and maybe especially, a child. Physically abusing another adult is considered a crime and when it involves a child, is often considered reprehensible as well. It is argued that a civilized society should not permit a child to be abused simply because of a lack of imagination regarding less physical discipline techniques. Is corporal punishment a positive, healthy and effective way to discipline a child or does this practice teach the child that violence is an accepted way to handle problems? The ‘spanking culture’ includes the majority of U.S. and U.K. households as evidenced by the fact that a majority of parents not only believe corporal punishment is the correct method for the home, they want it to be reintroduced in schools to tackle what they perceive is an increasing problem of classroom disorder. “Fifty-one percent of parents think reintroduction of corporal punishment is the answer to the problem. Among working class parents, 60 percent are in favor, 40 percent among middle class parents” (Carvel, 2000). The strongest supporters for corporal punishment in the United States are the National Association of Secondary School Principals, a large majority of fundamentalist churches and the American Federation of Teachers. As of 1985, 47 percent of the general American population were in favor of corporal punishment in the schools and 60 percent of school officials of various rank were also in favor of more physical disciplinary techniques in schools (“Corporal Punishment”, 2003). For most, it is believed that the threat of corporal punishment by teachers and administrators produces children who are “better controlled, learn appropriate appreciation for authority, develop better social skills, as well as improved moral character and learn to better discipline themselves” (“Corporal Punishment”, 2003). To a large extent, the research supports this contention when corporal punishment is carried out with reason, restraint and reliability among younger children. (Baumrind, 1989). Recent studies have indicated that long term effects of discipline techniques will depend to a great deal upon the method by which they are carried out and the parameters that determine the type of punishment given. According to Larzelere’s (2000) findings, whether children experience negative or positive outcomes from discipline techniques depends on the rate of recurrence of any disciplinary approach. This includes all types of discipline and does not single out corporal punishment. Consequently, it is determined to be excessive recurrences of bad behavior that is the root-cause of negative outcomes such as excessive punishment – children are not bad because they’ve been spanked but are spanked because they’ve been bad. Parents understand that recurring bad behavior will hamper their child’s chances for a successful life as an adult and feel compelled to diminish poor behavioral patterns with disciplinary techniques they believe to be most effective. It is the parents’ understanding that should be used as a guide as to how the schools should respond to behavior problems. (Hernandez, 2007). According to Rajmohan, 2000, in contrast to the punishment technique, Gandhi suggested a more positive approach involving reasoning with the child regarding their behavior and thus encouraging self-awareness. Care should be taken toward the rearing of children and the correction of anti-social activities so that the child is able to learn something positive from the experience rather than reinforcing conceptions of control through physical force and pain. When acting in response to bad behaviour, an argument based on Gandhi’s approach indicates parents should apply mild corrective actions such as reasoning, grounding and time-out. (Rajmohan, 2000). It’s an interesting facet of this society that hitting a child in considered parenting but hitting an adult is considered assault. “It is extraordinary that children, whose developmental state makes them particularly vulnerable to physical and psychological injury should have less legal protection from assault in a majority of member states than adults have” (Bargholtz, 2004). Psychiatrists are conflicted on the merits/detriments of spanking. Some believe the practice to be harmful while others parents “could use mild to moderate corporal punishment effectively.” (Gershoff, 2002). Spanking, if it absolutely must be used, has been shown to be most effective when it only used to re-enforce these milder corrective actions carried out in the home. Studies have demonstrated that spanking serves to increase the chance that the child will respond to mild corrective tactics. Sometimes it serves as a reminder to a mind not yet fully developed enough to fully consider the future consequences of actions and sometimes it is a deterrent to future similar behavior within a given setting. While children may learn they can do certain things at home, such as stand on furniture perhaps, this can be a dangerous activity in a busy classroom and may need more forceful reminders regarding what is not permitted in school. As a consequence of a child’s natural learning ability, spanking accompanied with efforts to ensure the child understands the reason for physical punishment, is needed less to control behaviour as the child grows older. “Spanking has consistently beneficial outcomes when it is non-abusive (e.g., two swats to the buttocks with an open hand) and used primarily to back up milder disciplinary tactics with 2- to 6-year-olds by loving adults . . . most detrimental outcomes in causally relevant studies are due to overly frequent use of physical punishment” (Larzelere, 2000: 215). Within the school system, these types of punishment techniques are frequently approached very systematically, ensuring that the child receives the explanation of why spanking is necessary and that the spanking given is not abusive, excessive or overly frequent without investigating other causes of behavior issues. Many parents and researchers alike are of the opinion that “parents have to be the parents. You can’t let the children run circles around you, which they will. Kids want to push their limits” (Etheridge, 1997). This same consideration should be extended into the classroom where teachers must deal with not just one or two children but sometimes as many as 30, all of whom are expected to have a certain level of knowledge at the end of a short season of learning. In addition, there are safety concerns. If a child is repeating unsafe behaviour such as climbing the furniture or darting out into the street, teachers have to stop the child by any means necessary. If reasoning with the child is not effective or the child is too young to understand either the rationale or the danger, a quick swat on the backside may ultimately serve to save their life. These arguments are repeated in triplicate when the child enters school and there are numerous individuals jockeying against each other for social status within their grade level or institution. The argument holds that teachers must retain control of the classroom and the only way to provide them with this type of control, given the numbers of students they must contend with on a daily basis, is to provide them with the right to spank a child who is misbehaving. “They are of the opinion that if this technique is thus removed, greater disciplinary difficulty in our schools and reduced teacher security will result” (Climinillo, 1980). In schools where the possibility of corporal punishment has been removed, this has indeed been the case as students begin to realize that the school itself, and the teachers in it, can do nothing to force them to behave and begin to run wild about the classroom. Many of the strongest complaints against the use of corporal punishment in the schools are based on people’s awareness of the possibility of abusing the right. Severe punishment, which is suspected in at least 30 percent of those families employing corporal punishment, is described as hitting which was “intended to or had the potential to or actually did cause physical and/or psychological injury or harm to the child” (Nobes, 1997). In the United States, it was determined through a Gallup Poll that 74 percent of children under the age of 5 had been hit by their parents by 1995 with 90 percent of the responding parents with children under the age of three reported having spanked their children as a means of disciplining them (Wauchope & Straus, 1990). These numbers are supported by a number of other studies in which it has been determined that the great majority of children in America have been subjected to spanking as a form of acceptable discipline. However, it is unclear how many of these cases involved what would be categorized as ‘severe punishment’ and it has already been shown how the use of corporal punishment within the school setting could be easily regulated to prevent such harsh treatment of a child when it is necessary. When practiced with discipline on the part of the adult and used as a last resort when a child simply refuses to behave even after they have been made aware of the consequences to others, corporal punishment can be an effective tool to reinforce learning outcomes in children, particularly those who are younger and have less ability to reason or to think ahead. Allowing a systematic approach to spanking within the school systems would provide the teachers with a very real and potentially greatly effective means of regaining control over the classroom. (Lyons, 1993). Those who are not so well informed and choose to base their opinions on perhaps their own abusive situations as children argue against this claiming it is tantamount to criminal brutality. The majority of parents that spank their children are not abusive by nature. They do so because they are concerned about properly socializing and protecting their offspring, a natural inclination also found in most species of animals. (Trumbull, 1996). Most parents would gladly opt for other forms of corrective measures if they only worked. Positive parenting methods such as those suggested by Gandhi that involve treating a child as if they are actually human beings with the capacity for reasoned thought and the right to be respected can work well for older children, but there is a general perception that the still underdeveloped minds of young children are not capable of grasping the fine nuances of such measures. The evidence has shown that sustained spanking leads to future behavioral problems but an occasional swat to those children under seven years of age used only as a last resort complemented with sound judgment and a loving environment is probably the favorable method by which to discipline children whether at school or at home. Works Cited Baumrind, Diana, Ph.D. "Rearing Competent Children." Damon, W. (Ed.) Child Development Today and Tomorrow. pp.349-378. San Francisco, Calif.: Jossey-Bass. (1989). Bargholtz, Helena. “Europe-wide Ban on Corporal Punishment of Children.” Social, Health and Family Affairs Committee Doc. 10199. Presented to Council of Europe Parliamentary Assembly. (June 4, 2004). July 25, 2009 Carvel, John. “Parents Call for Schools to Bring Back the Cane.” The Guardian. London, (January 8, 2000). Climinillo, LM. “Discipline: The School’s Dilemma.” Adolescence. Vol. 15, (1980): pp. 1-12. “Corporal Punishment in Schools.” Journal of Adolescent Health. Position paper of the Society for Adolescent Medicine. Vol. 32, (2003): pp. 385-393. Etheridge, Pat. “Study: Spanking Kids Leads to Long-Term Bad Behavior.” Cable News Network. (August 14, 1997). Gershoff, Elizabeth Thompson “Corporal Punishment by Parents and Associated Child Behaviors and Experiences: A Meta-Analytic and Theoretical Review” Columbia University. Psychological Bulletin American Psychological Association, Inc. Vol. 128, No. 4, 539–579 (2002). July 25, 2009 Hernandez, Walter E. “Parents Need to Teach Their Children How to Behave.” Topics Magazine. (2007). July 25, 2009 < http://www.topics-mag.com/edition10/child-raising-el-salvador.htm > Larzelere, Robert E. “Child Outcomes of Nonabusive and Customary Physical Punishment by Parents: An Updated Literature Review.” Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review. Vol. 3, N. 4, (2000): pp. 199-221. Lyons, Dr. John S., Anderson, Rachel L., and Larson, Dr. David B. “The Use and Effects of Physical Punishment in the Home: A Systematic Review.” Presentation to the Section on Bio-Ethics of the American Academy of Pediatrics at annual meeting, (Nov. 2, 1993). Ni, J.K. “Spanking Denounced as Ineffective, Harmful – Expert at Families Alive [conference] Urges Positive Discipline.” Deseret News. (1998). Nobes, Gavin. “Physical Punishment of Children in Two-Parent Families.” Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry. Vol. 2, N. 2, (1997): pp. 271 – 281. SAGE Publications Rajmohan, R. MK Gandhi Institute for Nonviolence. (2000). July 25, 2009 Trumbull, Den A.  “Spare the rod? New Research Challenges Spanking Critics.”  Family Policy. (Oct. 1996). July 25, 2009 Wauchope, BA & Straus, MA. “Physical Punishment and Physical Abuse of American Children: Incidence Rates by Age, Gender and Occupational Class.” Physical Violence in American Families. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction, 1990. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Spanking, a Necessary Evil Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words, n.d.)
Spanking, a Necessary Evil Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words. https://studentshare.org/education/1726090-argumentative-research-paper-why-we-should-continue-to-spank-our-children-for-misbehaving-despite-anti-spanking-research-and-spanking-critics-that-suggests-that-spanking-children-has-long-term-negative-effects
(Spanking, a Necessary Evil Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words)
Spanking, a Necessary Evil Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words. https://studentshare.org/education/1726090-argumentative-research-paper-why-we-should-continue-to-spank-our-children-for-misbehaving-despite-anti-spanking-research-and-spanking-critics-that-suggests-that-spanking-children-has-long-term-negative-effects.
“Spanking, a Necessary Evil Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words”. https://studentshare.org/education/1726090-argumentative-research-paper-why-we-should-continue-to-spank-our-children-for-misbehaving-despite-anti-spanking-research-and-spanking-critics-that-suggests-that-spanking-children-has-long-term-negative-effects.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF (Spanking, a Necessary Evil

Responsibility as a Core Value

Name: Instructor's name: Course: Date: Responsibility as a core value Several values have been integrated in the society with the main focus of the integration is to develop the necessary social controls in the society.... Values such as ethics, integrity and honesty have been used to define several requirements in the work places and other sectors of operation (Chase 34)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Is Speaking of Addiction in Terms of Sin Illuminating or Dangerous

Augustine's view is perhaps more illuminating in that according to Augustine, human evil originates out of the “self-imposed, radical bondage of the will” (Harkins, 2008, p.... Is Speaking of Addiction in Terms of Sin Illuminating, Dangerous, or Both?... When Christians speak of sin, it is connected to a duty to obey God and is therefore different from secular moral reasoning (Delkeskamp-Hayes, 2007)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Episcopal and Presbyterian

An appropriate Catholic response would appear to include the following elements, which flow from a fundamental belief in the dignity of each individual human being and the imperative to seek the universal common good in solidarity with the poorest, the weakest, the oppressed and the marginalized:* a recognition of the reality of sin and evil in the world and the duty of Christians to resist evils such as oppression, social and economic injustices, and genocide;* actively to seek to address the causes of grievances and conflicts in social, economic, and political inequalities which fail to treat every person and nation with appropriate dignity and respect;* the establishment of appropriate international institutions for the reconciliation of differences, with legitimacy and the authority to enforce compliance;* a recognition that an option for non-violence is as important an imperative for Christians as the option for the poor;* focus more than previously on alternatives to war, the need to promote social justice as an integral element in the following of Jesus, to fund peace education programs, and so forth;* the promotion of agreed and internationally regulated arms reduction;* in so far as armed responses to evils such as genocide are necessary, they should conform to the principles of the just war, and particularly proportionality and discrimination;* the need for this to be undertaken speedily and effectively by reformed international institutions with legitimacy and powers of enforcement;* the creation of a strong international civil society with a commitment to human dignity and rights; and* the promotion o...
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Some Aspect of Romanticism in Blake's The Marriage of Heaven and Hell

This poem was one of Blake's most innovative works both stylistically as well as thematically.... The poem settles around Blake's… Blake's poem is highly complex and not one that could be easily categorized into any one genre, nor is it easy to interpret. William Blake was not only and outstanding writer, but also an engraver par excellence....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Peter Pan Syndrome

Barrie which uses conflicting concepts such as aging and youthfulness, enchantment and reality, as well as the eternal struggle between good and evil to present the theme of immaturity.... In fact, a Harvard college professor, Maria Tatar, cited the importance of reading fairy tales to young children....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

The Social and Ethical Modifications

hellip; This is morally wrong and should not be used as a basis for someone to fail to contribute towards the resolving of a preventable evil.... He drives home the point that people should feel obligated to as much as they can support the poor and the suffering, and counter any form of preventable evil (Singer, 1972)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Loss of Values

This paper ''The Loss of Values'' tells that according to the philosopher Aristotle, human beings are, by nature, political animals: they are inextricably tied into vast networks of social relationships that extend beyond any means of measurement.... nbsp;… But loss need not be of a value of a concrete thing: it can be of an abstraction, an ideal, that once lost, can rarely be fully regained....
5 Pages (1250 words) Article

The Ethical Issue and Options of the Business

Bribery is a social evil and grooming it will lead to a further serious consequence like the erosion of morals and ethical business operations.... This essay "The Ethical Issue and Options of the Business" presents an ethical dilemma - bribery.... The new station Franz Mueller depicts how Mueller has the habit of soliciting bribes to the manufacturer's sales managers by giving out Rolex watches....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us