StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Impact of NAFTA agreement on the US Economy - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper aims at exploring how the trade agreement called NAFTA that the US has entered into with Mexico and Canada has impacted on the domestic industries and the US economy at large. The paper would also explore how the devaluation of the US Dollar against the Chinese Yuan can bring respite to the US manufacturing industries                     …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Impact of NAFTA agreement on the US Economy
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Impact of NAFTA agreement on the US Economy"

 In the wake of globalization and liberalization, international trade has increased manifold. In fact, it is in the benefit of international consumers as they get the quality goods at the lowest possible prices; however, many economists oppose it as it affects domestic manufacturers. It is worth pondering on the root causes behind the ever increasing global trade. The paper aims at exploring how the trade agreement called NAFTA that the US has entered into with Mexico and Canada has impacted on the domestic industries and the US economy at large. The paper would also explore how the devaluation of the US Dollar against the Chinese Yuan can bring respite to the US manufacturing industries. Suranovic (2010) describes about some important key-reasons that decide about any trade between the nations and they are worth pondering to understand the burgeoning global trade. Resource Advantage Each country is endowed with certain natural resources such as minerals, water, land, fossil fuels, and essential raw materials and accordingly their strength lies in manufacturing those finished goods where such resources are necessary. Obviously, such resource pool will put certain countries in advantage over others. Technological Superiority Technological superiority of one country over other in a particular product will facilitate production of better quality goods at lower cost and that superiority puts one country ahead of others in a particular good. If the US produces Boeing aircraft and fighters or other sophisticated warheads then it is because of the technological superiority that the US exerts over others in this field. Government Regulations Trades between the nations are also impacted by the subsidies provided to domestic producers or tariffs imposed on the imported goods. Subsidies will artificially reduce the cost of domestic producers and tariffs will increase the cost of imports thus jeopardizing the international trade. For a free international trade, it is essential that such tax barriers do not exist between the nations. Absolute Advantage vs. Comparative Advantage Douma & Schreuder (2008) argue that the country that shows highest productivity levels over others in a particular good will be considered to have absolute advantage in producing that good. It is a fact that the US has absolute advantage in producing grains as it needs fewer real resources relative to the most of the countries in the world. The availability of huge agricultural land and the use of machines are the major reasons in having absolute advantage in agriculture. The country uses minimal labor per unit area of agricultural land increasing the productivity levels manifold; however, it is essential to note that absolute cost advantage does not determine the production and allocation of labor for producing a good but it is the comparative advantage that gives rise to the production of a particular good in that country. The comparative advantage takes into account the opportunity cost while producing a particular good in that country (Suranovic, 2011). This fundamental reality drives the trade globally and the NAFTA agreement is to be seen in this light. US Trade Balance with NAFTA Partners and the World in the year 1989 and 2009 (In billions of current USD) Source: O’Leary et al, 2012, p13. It is important to note here that there is no appreciable change in balance of trade in agriculture commodity with Mexico and Canada; there is no significant impact on the US labor force involved in agriculture. In all merchandise trade with Mexico and Canada in 2009, imports have increased by almost 45 billion and 11 billion USD respectively but so is the case with world trade which shows negative balance of 500 billion USD. This clearly shows that NAFTA trade has followed the world trend only and nothing specific can be attributed to NAFTA agreement that the US has entered into (O’Leary et al, 2012). Below mentioned table indicates about the employment changes between 1989 and 2008 in the key industries in the US. This change is attributed to all international trade that the US is engaged with various countries in the world. Employment Change in Traded Goods Industries, United States, 1989-2008 Industry Employment (thousands) 1989 2008 % change (1993-2008) Agricultural Products 1137 951 -10.4 Textiles & Fabrics 496 157.6 -67.3 Apparel Manufacturing 936.2 221.4 -75.0 Leather & Allied 131.4 36.1 -70.1 All traded goods Industries 20506 17001 -18.5 Source: O’Leary et al, 2012, p14. . Due to various trade agreements between 1989 and 2009, the major impact has been felt by textiles, apparel, and leather industries in the US where the displacement of workers has been highest. The noteworthy point is that the US imports in these three sectors are not from Canada or Mexico but they are mainly from China, Taiwan, Korea and India. This also indicates that NAFTA has not been instrumental in displacing workers from these three industries in the US. Understanding Impact of NAFTA on the US Labor Force Ever since the day NAFTA was signed until 2001, real US exports to Mexico increased by 93 percent, by 35 percent with Canada and by 20 percent with non-NAFTA countries. The US import from Mexico increased by 190 percent, from Canada by 69 percent and by 59 percent from non-NAFTA countries. The trade increased employment in trading countries. The US International Trade Commission tried to find the effect of NAFTA on various manufacturing sectors and concluded that 109 industrial sectors had absolutely no effect from NAFTA. Only seven sectors were really affected from NAFTA. The Department of Agriculture also tried to find the effect of NAFTA on rural employment. They finally concluded that rural employment was increased by 0.07 percent in 1996 than would have been possible without NAFTA. In the study done by Krueger, it was found that NAFTA had a positive impact on exports but statistically it was not significant. These results indicate that NAFTA had a small and statistically insignificant impact on employment status of the US (O’Leary et al, 2012). Devaluation of the Dollar against the Yuan, and the US Manufacturing The US was in forefront advocating the trade liberalization among nations removing import restrictions and tax-barriers across nations since quite a long time. Currently, China is a largest trading partner of the US in international trade. Following table speaks about imports and Exports numbers between these two countries. (In Billions of USD) Year 2012 (Up to September end) 2011 2010 2009 2008 Imports Exports Imports Exports Imports Exports Imports Exports Imports Exports Figures 310.97 78.79 399.36 103.94 364.94 91.88 296.37 69.49 337.77 69.73 Difference -232.18 -295.42 -273.063 -226.87 -268 Source: http://www.census.gov/foreign-trade/balance/c5700.html It is evident from the above table that the huge trade gap exists between these two countries. The US imports are rising every year compared to its exports to China. The experts look at the balance of payments issue of the US from the exchange rate perspective between the US dollar and the Chinese Yuan. The Chinese government has pegged Yuan at fixed exchange rate against dollar. The exchange rates between these two currencies are not free floating in the market thus, keeping the currency depreciated artificially. This makes Chinese exports cheaper and imports costlier in the world. It is worth noting that China has strongly opposed the criticism made on its currency policy. In June 2010, the china's central bank allowed some flexibility on its exchange rate policy and the currency appreciated by 2.9 percent through the end of 2010. Critics and policy makers in the US are of the opinion that the balance of payment issue has its roots in undervalued Chinese currency. Many also state that the huge unemployment issue that the US has been facing since long has its reason lies in huge its trade deficit with China (Morrison & Labonte, 2010). In one of the study done by the Economic Policy Institute in the US, it was found that almost 2.4 million jobs in the US were displaced between 2001 and 2008 (Morrison & Labonte, 2010 p 6). The high unemployment rate that is hovering around 9 percent in the US since 2008 last quarter until date has a lot to do with trade differences between these two countries. Not only this but other East Asian countries are also forced to keep their currencies depreciated so that they can compete with Chinese onslaught in the international trade. Bergsten from the Peterson Institute for International Economics has estimated that if the Chinese currency is appreciated by 40 percent against the US dollar then it would create additional jobs between 600,000 and 1.2 million in the US (Morrison & Labonte, 2010 p 6). Economist Paul Krugman also opines that undervalued Yuan has become a major impediment in the global economic recovery (Morrison & Labonte, 2010 p.6). Reflection Despite a wide ranging controversy on international trade, it is a fact that currently, global world trade has reached to the level of almost $12,500 billion. It cannot be denied that international trade has brought efficiency in production processes and in deliverance of the goods. The world is producing higher economic output using lesser resources and consumers have benefitted from this immensely. The US has always been the biggest advocate of free trade since last several decades and it is always desirable that along with free international trade the currencies of the countries also trade freely in the international market so that unnecessary trade restrictions and tariffs are not imposed on each other. Again, it is a fact that NAFTA increased the real wages of the workers thus, whatever loss the countries had due to displacement of workers were compensated by the increase in aggregate incomes of the large section of the workers who participated in the free trade. It is quite clear that the idea of comparative advantage is here to stay because it brings the economic well being of the masses across the world. Displacement of the workers is harsh reality of free trade and that needs to be tackled through skill improvement and education; government needs to provide extra resources and run a special drive to settle the workers in a profession where comparative advantage can change their fortunes. References Douma, S. W.; Schreuder, H. (2008). Economic Approaches to Organizations. Prentice Hall, New York. Print. Foreign Trade (2012). Trade in Goods with China. Retrieved November 23 2012 from http://www.census.gov/foreign-trade/balance/c5700.html Morrison W. M.; Labonte, M. (2010). China’s Currency: An Analysis of the Economic Issues. Congressional Research Service. Retrieved November 23, 2012 from http://fpc.state.gov/documents/organization/154184.pdf O’Leary, C. J., Eberts, R. W. and Pittelko, B. M. (2012), “Effects of NAFTA on US Employment and Policy Responses”, OECD Trade Policy Working Papers, No. 131, OECD Publishing. Suranovic, S. (2011). International Trade: Theory and Policy. Retrieved July 23, 2012 from http://catalog.flatworldknowledge.com/bookhub/reader/28 Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Impact of NAFTA agreement on the US Economy Research Paper, n.d.)
Impact of NAFTA agreement on the US Economy Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1787056-you-choose-any-topic-about-international-trade
(Impact of NAFTA Agreement on the US Economy Research Paper)
Impact of NAFTA Agreement on the US Economy Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1787056-you-choose-any-topic-about-international-trade.
“Impact of NAFTA Agreement on the US Economy Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1787056-you-choose-any-topic-about-international-trade.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Impact of NAFTA agreement on the US Economy

Does AFTA Create or Divert Trade

The paper “Does AFTA Create or Divert Trade” delves into the changes in trade patterns that have occurred with the implementation of AFTA agreement in 1992.... hellip; The author states that the long term goal of the agreement is to achieve a more powerful ASEAN Economic Community by 2015 by establishing a free market where the goods, services, and labor can flow freely.... The AFTA agreement aims at promoting free trade in the region by bringing down the tax barriers....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

The North America Free Trade Agreement

Most of those issues concern whether NAFTA has or has not benefited the economies of the three countries involved in the agreement. … One report says, "years after its passage, a look at the effects of nafta across all three countries illustrates an overwhelmingly negative picture" (Faux, 2001).... One report says, "years after its passage, a look at the effects of nafta across all three countries illustrates an overwhelmingly negative picture" (Faux, 2001)....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Impact of NAFTA on Mexico

While the Mexican economy has suffered when it comes to agricultural sector, it has made tremendous gains in other sectors which have made the overall affect of the agreement to be positive for Mexico.... As more studies are made into the topic, the picture is likely to get clearer for all concerned parties but as of now, the NAFTA has been a blessing for the Mexican economy rather than a curse.... NAFTA was established as a free trade agreement between Mexico, Canada and America and it has become one of the most debated free trade agreements in the world....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

International Business and North American Free Trade Agreement

Canada now has an extension of duty drawbacks and greater discipline over standards, which should reduce border conflicts with the us.... I would like to underscore, as well that the best part of the agreement in my opinion is that Canada, along with the us and Mexico have the same low or zero most favored nation tariff on imports such as computers.... As it is, there are countries and firms who prefer Canada over Mexico because the country's labor pool is skilled and educated; and over the us, because of the appeal of lower costs and a moderate tax regime....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

CritiqueThe Analysis of the United Nations and WIPO

Politics & economy.... For example, the foreign corrupt practices act which was formed with an intention of stopping bribery of foreign official ad prohibit us citizens and firm from making improper payments to foreign officials.... Washington Times - Politics, Breaking News, us and World News.... It can also be pointed out that the formation of those organization in paper one is signed and ratified by the member states unlike in paper two where the only the head of states are endowed with authority of signing of the agreement....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Analysis of State of Massachusetts on North American Free Trade Agreement

hus, the vote on the North American Free Trade agreement was an almost evenly divisive issue for Democrats senators during the vote in 1993, where 27 democrat senators voted for the NAFTA implementation, while 28 of the Democrat senators voted against its implementation (Earle, 193).... The most notable occurrence, however, is that both the Democrat senators from the State of Massachusetts voted for the implementation of the NAFTA trade agreement, despite the issue being highly divisive....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

International development is/is not best helped through free trade

According to findings of a research sponsored by the us Department of Commerce, free trade has opened up most countries around the world by providing them with virtually unlimited access to markets in other regions.... According to findings of a research sponsored by the us Department of Commerce, free trade has opened up most countries around the world by providing them with virtually unlimited access to markets in other regions.... The researcher will use case studies to demonstrate real examples of the impact of the impact of free trade on development....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Proposal

Should the Multinational Firm Be Involved In International Business or Investment with a Developing Country

The improvement of the Chinese economy Influences its people to spend more which becomes an advantage in its retail industry.... The economic system of China has become market-oriented economy.... The country has become a significant player in a global economy....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us