StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Is there any value in E.H. Carr's dictum: 'before you study the history, study the historian' - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
E.H. Carr's dictum: 'before you study the history, study the historian' describes that the facts of history do not come to the readers as intact as it could be because they do not exist in "pure" form, they always come with the interpretation of the user of facts (Tosh 2006)…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.2% of users find it useful
Is there any value in E.H. Carrs dictum: before you study the history, study the historian
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Is there any value in E.H. Carr's dictum: 'before you study the history, study the historian'"

Download file to see previous pages

He traced his family background through the great Whig historian, George Otto Trevelyan and by doing so he investigated the origin and development of the Whig tradition. And even though it is not the only interpretation of Queen Anne's reign, it is a valid and, in Trevelyan's hands, a fruitful interpretation (Trevelyan 1949). Thus to appreciate significance of a history, the reader should know and understand what the historian is doing. Collingwood (1994) states that historians must re-enact in thought what has gone on in the mind of his dramatis personae, so the reader will also re-enact what goes on in the mind of the historian.

Thus reading a work of history should be coupled with listening to what is 'bubbly'. If one cannot detect something, there is something wrong with how the history was understood or how it was presented. The facts here were treated like fishes swimming in a vast ocean which is sometimes inaccessible to anyone. What the historian catches will depend partly on chance. His choices on what part of the ocean to fish and what equipment to use will depend on the kind of fish he wants to catch. By that, the historian will get the kind of facts he wants.

Thus, history means the interpretation of the historian (Carr 1961). Another example of how the philosophy of British historian E. H. . it was the image of his father which dominated and obsessed his being . . - and even the icy detachment and indifference of Lord Randolph failed to destroy the proud and passionate allegiance of his sonUntil the end he worshipped at the altar of his Unknown Father. (Carter 1965) It was seen in his writings that Winston Churchill provides a considerable evidence of filial hero-worship.

In Thoughts and Adventures, he writes that: the greatest and most powerful influence in my early life was of course my father. . . .1 conceived an intense admiration and affection for him - and, after his death, for his memory, I read industriously almost every word he had ever spoken and learnt by heart large portions of his speeches. Indeed, the workings of Winston Churchill about his father, Randolph could be best understood in this context. The views of Collingwood on the philosophy of history could expound more the E. H. Carr's dictum.

It was told that the history is neither "the past by itself" nor with "the historian's thought about it by itself," but both in their mutual relations. This reflects the two current meanings of the word "history" - the enquiry conducted by the historian and the series of past events into which he enquires. Collingwood argued that the past is meaningless to the historian unless he can understand the thought underlying it. Thus, it could be said that "all history is the history of thought," and "history is the re-enactment in the historian's mind of the thought whose history he is studying.

" According to Professor Oakeshott, whose point stands near to Collingwood, "history is the historian's experience (Oakeshott 1933). Carr's dictum mirrored his stance on relativism.

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Is there any value in E.H. Carr's dictum: 'before you study the Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1529766-is-there-any-value-in-eh-carrs-dictum-before-you-study-the-history-study-the-historian
(Is There Any Value in E.H. Carr's Dictum: 'Before You Study the Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1529766-is-there-any-value-in-eh-carrs-dictum-before-you-study-the-history-study-the-historian.
“Is There Any Value in E.H. Carr's Dictum: 'Before You Study the Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1529766-is-there-any-value-in-eh-carrs-dictum-before-you-study-the-history-study-the-historian.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Is there any value in E.H. Carr's dictum: 'before you study the history, study the historian'

Strategic Management of Lonely Planet Company

Going by the history of the company as far as its financial articulation is of concern, Lonely Planet has… This is a clear indication that the company has outstanding marketing strategies, keeping in mind that it has a variety of writers who in turn provides quality writings.... Going by the history of the company as far as its financial articulation is of concern, Lonely Planet has grown rapidly with typical annual sales increase of 15 percent or more....
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

Online Shoes, Clothing, Free Shipping, and Returns

Most customers end up Case study: Zappos al affiliation Case study: Zappos Zappos is an online shop that mostly deals with women, men and children clothesand shoes.... The other core value that can be influenced through training and development is, do more with less (Zappos.... Embracing and driving change is another core value that cannot be influenced (Zappos....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Case study for the value chain analysis

Case study.... value chain analysis examines the activities of a business and connects them to the competitive strength of the organization (Grant, Hackney and Edgar 10).... The company has created a network of 25 local farms to Chipotle Mexican Grill The best way to comprehend the way a business creates a competitive advantage is to analyze its value chain.... value chain analysis examines the activities of a business and connects them to the competitive strength of the organization (Grant, Hackney and Edgar 10)....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Duty to Provide Care Practice Standards

Thus, if you fail to cater to your patients under such conditions, then you might just be held liable for Joy Case study Joy Case study Medical practitioners such as nurses, therapists and doctors, normally ask whether declining or evenwithdrawing care might be considered as client abandonment (CRNBC, 2015).... Your answer relies on whether or not you have developed a relationship with the client or you chose to… This is according to the Duty to Provide Care Practice Standards that every practitioner accepts to obey before they start practice (CRNBC, 2015)....
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

The Adlerian Approach

The abilities difference cause attraction of Case study the Adlerian approach assumes that people always have a purpose for their behavior (Dinkmeyer, 2007).... Individuals create their personal values based on early… As a counselor, then encourage what each is doing to maintain the family wellbeing in making them aware that you know their plans.... As a counselor, then encourage what each is doing to maintain the family wellbeing in making them aware that you know their plans....
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

London Ships of Historic Interest Partnership

The study is to develop the marketing plan for the new project and explains how London's SHIPS is planning to target a number of new international markets and also how necessary to develop a new marketing plan before targeting the new markets.... The main audience could be school and college goers, research scholars in ancient British maritime history and other people.... “Environmental analysis will help you understand what is happening both inside and outside your organization and to increase the probability that the organizational strategies you develop will appropriately reflect your organizational environment....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Land Study: Rookery South Energy-from-Waste Generating Station

This case study "Land study: Rookery South Energy-from-Waste Generating Station" presents waste management that is a pressing issue in the developed world as firms, households, schools, hospitals, and hotels among other facilities continue to churn out waste on a daily basis.... Therefore, this proposal shall address the impact the development will have on the people, environment, land history, transport, and communication systems in Bedfordshire County....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us