StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Tracking an Offender After a Crime - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Tracking an Offender After a Crime" fcouses on the critical analysis of the case known as the People of the State of California v. Orenthal James Simpson is the name of the criminal trial held against O.J Simpson after he had murdered his wife…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.3% of users find it useful
Tracking an Offender After a Crime
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Tracking an Offender After a Crime"

Tracking an Offender after a Crime al Affiliation Step This essay chose to analyze a case featured in CNN on 4 October 2000. This case is known as the People of the State of California v. Orenthal James Simpson is the name of the criminal trial held against O.J Simpson after he had murdered his wife. Simpson was a former American Football star and an actor. He was arrested and tried on two counts of murder of both his Ex-wife and her friend Ronald Goldman. This case has attained publicity as the most publicized criminal case in American History (Rantala, 2001). Simpson acquittal occurred after a lengthy trial that lasted for more than 8 months. This essay analyses the case of O.J Simpson and the offences that he committed. The main aim of this essay is to show knowledge of the criminal Justice system and the processes involved in this institution (Uelmen, 2009. His case was presided over by Judge Lance. The case of Simpson was characterized by hiring of a highly professional defense team, which was initially lead by Robert Shapiro. Step 2 Simpson was arrested in police car chase in Los Angeles. His arrest was a public arrest and it was watched on the national television by the national audience. During the time of Simpson’s arrest, he was running away from Los Angeles. The police managed to locate him through a vehicle that his friend was driving. Simpson explained to the police that he had a firearm and he would commit suicide if the police would stop his car by force. The police on a cellular phone promised that they would not stop him forcefully. This event was aired in the television since the Los Angeles Helicopters captured the scene. His arrest and trial ignited a national debate of race, corruption in the legal system and fame resulted into a highly publicized case (Uelmen 2009. Simpson was arrested and tried on 20th June and he pleaded not guilty for both murders. As it is stipulated in the United States constitution, the judge ordered that he should be held without bail. On the day that followed, there was a conference of a jury so that they could discuss and reach a consensus whether they should indict Simpson for the two murders. The jury was later dismissed after two days when due to excessive media coverage. This was done because it appeared as if the media coverage in this case would affect neutrality of this case. Jill Shively was the witness of this case who testified to the judges that he had actually seen Simpson when he was speeding away from the area surrounding Nicole’s house during the night of the Murder (Rantala 2001). The second witness of this case was Jose Camacho who worked at a cutlery shop (Simpson 2007). In his testimony, he claimed to have sold a German made knife that was 15 inches long. After these two witnesses had sold their story to the press, they were not resented by the prosecution at the criminal trial. The television show paid $500 to Shiverly after she had made the testimony to them. On the other hand, Camacho did sell his story to the National Enquirer at $ 12500. Later, a probable cause hearing was held to determine whether it was right to bring Simpson to trial. This was a minor victory for Simpson’s lawyers since they now got evidence of the case as it was being presented to the prosecution and contrast it to the grand jury ruling (Rice 2002). On 7th July, Kthleen Kennedy Powell who was a California superior court judge ruled that there was insufficient evidence to bring Simpson into trial for the murders. On 29th July, Simpson was asked how he pled for the case during this arraignment. He reacted by breaking a court practice which says that the accused should plead in simple words of “guilty” “not guilty”. In fact, he firmly stated that he was absolutely and one hundred percent not guilty (Simpson 2007). Investigation of the Murder case of Simpson was then launched and the case was televised for 134 days (Rosenberg 1994). Tom Lange who was a Los Angeles Police department detective was in charge of this investigation. The prosecution chooses to ask for life sentencing instead of death penalty for this case (Uelmen 2009). The exposure of this case in the television made the figures involved in this case to be celebrities. Simpson wanted a speedy trial, therefore, the defense and the prosecution worked hard to conduct his trial on time. In October 1994, Judge started interviewing the 304 prospective judges. They were expected to fill a questionnaire that was seventy-five pages long. Simpson’ trial began in 24th January 1995 and t was continuously televised by Court TV and other news outlets. Christopher Darden who was the chief prosecutor of this case argued that Simpson killed his Ex-wife out of rage that was caused by jealousy. They began this case with the evidence from a 9-1-1 call that Nicole Brown had made to the police department on 1st January 1989(Rantala 2001). In this recorded call, she made a clear expression of the fear she had that Simpson could harm her physically. There was Simpson’s voice in the background as he yelled. The prosecution presented DNA finger print analysis, shoeprint and blood analysis that linked Simpson to the crime scene. The prosecution presented the incriminating evidence against Simpson during the opening weeks. Simpson’s lawyer had the argument that only a single proportion of women who are abused by their men are murdered. The defense attorneys in this case included Carl E. Douglas, Robert Shapiro, Robert Kardashian, F. Lee Bailey and Gerald Uelmen. The evidence presented at the trial of Simpson was of various kinds. It includes a DNA analysis of blood found in Simpson’s pair of socks and it clearly indicated that this bloodstain belonged to Nicole Brown. Both socks had about twenty stains of blood and this blood was identical to Nicole’s blood. In addition, the left-hand grove that was found at Nicole Browns home matched with the right hand grove that was found at Simpsons’ house. The DNA analysis of the left hand grove that contained blood proved to be Nicole Brown’s blood. The carpet had stains that were fibers from Simpsons Bronco. Goldman’s shirt was also found to contain a few strands of African American Hair. The officer also found past arrest records that clearly showed that Simpson used to constantly assault his wife. These records included photographs of Brown after being battered by Simpson in an attack. There was so much evidence presented as incriminating evidence in this case. The burden of proof was left to Simpson and his defense layers. The prosecution side of this case felt that they had a very strong case. They did not have the murder weapon or witnesses of the murder. The physical evidence that they collected suggested that Simpson drove to Brown’s house with an intention of murder. The prosecution also suspected that Nicole came to the door to respond to a door knock after taking her children to bed (Simpson 2007). He grabbed Nicole Brown before she could scream and he attacked her with a knife. Forensic evidence that followed suggested that he Goldman actually came to the scene of crime during the assault and Simpson attacked him too (Rice 2002). He attacked her by stabbing her at the neck and the chest for several times. The prosecution also argued that some bloodstains were found on the way to Simpson’s house near his gate. The prosecution argues that Simpson was last seen in the public at 9.36 pm. This was the time he had returned at the front gate of his house with a friend. He was later seen after about one hour and 18 Minutes. The prosecution and the defense agree that the offense occurred between 10:15 and 10:40. The prosecutor presented a witness who confirmed that he had seen a Bronco that resembled Simpson’s car. The criminal trial of Simpson was a sensational event of the media since it was aired in most television stations in Los Angeles. It also brought about a great deal of racial divisions in America. In fact, some people began calling the US criminal Justice system into question. During the proceeding of his case, majority of Afrin-Americans believed Simpson consistently believed that Simpson was innocent of the murder of the victims of the murder of the two victims (Rosenberg 1994). On the other hand, the whites supported the Media and constantly believed that Simpson was guilty of the two murders. A jury made up of Two Whites and 9 African Americans and one Hispanic made a ruling that he was not guilty of the charges after only four hours. In a civil trial in 1997, Simpson was found answerable to several charges that were related to killings. He was sentenced to pay millions to compensate the punitive damages to the families of the victims. However, these families did not receive the complete compensation that he was penalized. Step 3 The weakest thing about the Criminal Justice System is the fact that it leaves the responsibility to make the judgment to on single person or a series of judges. The truth is that judges are also human (Rice 2002). Therefore, they are also subject to bias and err. In addition, they may be tribal, racist or even practice nepotism. In addition, the discretional powers in the criminal justice system are also another weak link. This is because it causes the growth of other criminal acts such as corruption, extortion, Police brutality, drug trafficking and apprehended goods. The truth is that discretionary powers predispose the signatories of the judiciary to a possibility of misuse of the power they are vested with by the constitution. On the hand a strong link about the Criminal Justice is the fact that it requires that both the prosecution and the victims should provide enough evidence to enhance the trial of facts in a court of law. This allows the prosecution to gather enough evidence during the processing of cases in the courts of law. Reference Hunt, D. M. (1999). O.J. Simpson facts and fictions: news rituals in the construction of reality. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Rosenberg, C. B. (1994). The trial of OJ: how to watch the trial and understand whats really going on. Los Angeles: Pub. Partners. Rantala, M. L. (2001). O.J. Unmasked: The Trial, the Truth, and the Media. Los Angeles: Open Court Publishing. Reiher, N. (2010). Reactions to the O.J. Simpson Verdict. Florida: GRIN Verlag. Rice, E. (2002). The O.J. Simpson Trial. Raleigh, N.C.: Lucent Books. Simpson, O. J., Dunne, D., & Fenjves, P. F. (2007). If I did it: confessions of the killer. New York: Beaufort Books. Uelmen, G. F. (2009). Lessons from the trial: the people v. O.J. Simpson. New York: Andrews and McMeel. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Tracking An Offender After a Crime Research Paper”, n.d.)
Tracking An Offender After a Crime Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1615992-tracking-an-offender-after-a-crime
(Tracking An Offender After a Crime Research Paper)
Tracking An Offender After a Crime Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1615992-tracking-an-offender-after-a-crime.
“Tracking An Offender After a Crime Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1615992-tracking-an-offender-after-a-crime.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Tracking an Offender After a Crime

Psychological Analysis of Sex Offenders

The guidelines are clearly outlined in the 'Jacob Wetterling Crimes Against Children Act of 1994, Megan's Law of 1996, and Pam Lechner Sexual offender Tracking and Identification Act of 1996' (Maddan, 2008, p.... The paper "Psychological Analysis of Sex Offenders" pinpoints that registration of sexual offenders is important since it deters offenders from repeat offenses, protects communities from the offenders, and assists authorities in keeping track of the offenders....
8 Pages (2000 words) Lab Report

California's sex offender registration

California's sex offender registration California's sex offender registration The California Department of Justice (DOJ) is the respective body responsible for the creation and maintenance of the sex offender's database.... ... ... ... The law of the state entails, as according to the California Penal Code section 290, that persons who are convicted of particular crimes, which are specified, must register themselves as ‘sex offenders' with the local law enforcement agency....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Offender Recidivism and Employment

precise figure for the rate of recidivism cannot be ascertained, as much crime goes unreported and the courts do not convict all offenders for various reasons, including lack of evidence.... However, the very nature of their offender status brings.... Study findings indicate that the effect of incarceration (versus other sentencing options) and sentence length on recidivism is complex and is likely to be offender-specific....
25 Pages (6250 words) Essay

Effectiveness of Registration and Notification Laws

ates to penalize sexual offenders and predators; and track them after released from legal custody believing that they have a high propensity to recidivate.... Specifically, this paper will study recidivism rates among registered sex offenders after release from incarceration or from any forms of legal punishment in two different states: 1.... Like Megan's Law, Wetterling Crimes against Children and Sexually Violent Offender Registration Act (named after Jacob Wetterling who was murdered when he was eleven) also requires sex offenders to register....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Should Offenders Be Subjected to Public Punishment

Sex abuse is a crime as it is against the penal code of the nation.... This term paper "Should Offenders Be Subjected to Public Punishment" tries to understand the victims, offenders, and the rate of prevalence of the crime.... In the US, after every two minutes, there is a sexual assault happening....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Assault in the City: Treatment

The success rate is high since the offender's sex drive becomes too low to facilitate sex.... There are different facilities for adults and children (juvenile).... A juvenile is a criminal below 18 years and is separated from adults to avoid bad influence from adult.... ... ... Inmates in both systems are punished for their crimes, depending on the magnitude of the offence....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Evaluating Sex Offender Programs

Sex offenders are individuals who confess to or have been convicted of carrying out a sex crime such as rape and child molestation.... This paper will discuss some particular sex offender programs.... The main aim of sex offender programs involves the protection and safety of the society.... Various issues have to be taken into account when evaluating the effectiveness of sex offender programs.... There has been progressing in understanding the features of effective sex offender programs, whose purpose is modifying both cognitive distortions as well as the deviant sexual behaviors in order to decrease the likelihood of re-offending....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

The Usefulness of Using Static Assessments to Predict Levels of Risk in Offenders

So as to appropriately direct offenders where they shall get the correct level of assistance or supervision, these factors are supposed to be reassessed after a given period.... To assess changes in an offender's risk level, the necessary thing is the knowledge of dynamic factors (Canter & Youngs, 2009).... While working in the criminal justice field, it is vital for someone to be able to correctly assess the probability that an offender can cause problems when confined, fail to complete post-release requirements, or re-offend once released as well as other issues that come up with offenders....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us