StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Are laws that protect us from our own dangerous behaviors (such seat belt or helmet) morally acceptable - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
There were various protests in Los Angeles due to the law passed by the California court according to which all the motorcyclists are suppose to wear helmets. Bikers wanted this law to be changed as they wanted freedom of choice, people who wants to wear it can wear it and people who are not interested in wearing them, will not wear it…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.7% of users find it useful
Are laws that protect us from our own dangerous behaviors (such seat belt or helmet) morally acceptable
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Are laws that protect us from our own dangerous behaviors (such seat belt or helmet) morally acceptable"

Download file to see previous pages

Controversies over the laws which are basically designed for protecting people from dangerous behavior are problems of paternalism. Paternalism is interference in people’s freedom though it is for their own good. It is like a father making decisions for his kids instead of letting the kids make decisions for them, considering one important thing that father knows best. Wide range and variety of laws, practices and actions are taken into account which is under the principles of paternalism. More like a doctor or physician deciding what is best for his patients and the laws which are designed to restrict the use of cocaine, marijuana, heroin and other drugs.

Such plans also include compulsory retirement plans, mandatory seatbelt laws which are designed to protect one’s interest whether they are liked by the people or people detest them. All these paternalistic practices are common, but the question is whether these practices are morally accepted or not. There is conflict of two important values attached with paternalism which include the value is taken into account for protecting and also promoting well being of others, along with the value which is associated with the freedom of persons which make their lead their life according to their wish and choice.

When the people are ready to act in certain ways oppose to their own well being and security , an important question arises that are the laws justified which interfere in people’s private choices and matters. This is what leads to the problem of paternalism. There is a majority who would agree that paternalism becomes a justified thing when it is about a person who has limited and also impaired freedom of choices whether the cause of this is limited cognitive capacities or even the ignorance of facts, effects of a disease, influence of drugs and another reason can be due to coercion.

Paternalism varies depending on the person, their emotional stability and behavior along with the capacity to understand and know what is best for them. According to many moral philosophers, a competent and a knowledgeable person should be allowed to make decisions freely and they should not be over ridden, though they are for their own person’s good. There was a case voiced by John Stuart Mill who was a British philosopher during the nineteenth century, according to him the only reason due to implement and make laws for the citizens and people of civilized community is to prevent problems and harm to others.

Will of one’s own being is not enough physically and even morally. The laws are made for a collective society and laws which are beneficial and important for protecting the society over all. According to Mill, it was important to provide freedom as it is important and crucial for people’s individual personality development. Along with that people should be given a free hand for making choices they wish and like even if the choices are not the best ones. All these individual choices creates ability for people to make decisions and their decision making power will only improve their practices and experiences.

Another important view which he holds was that individuals are the best judge for

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Are laws that protect us from our own dangerous behaviors (such seat Essay”, n.d.)
Are laws that protect us from our own dangerous behaviors (such seat Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1477225-are-laws-that-protect-us-from-our-own-dangerous
(Are Laws That Protect Us from Our Own Dangerous Behaviors (such Seat Essay)
Are Laws That Protect Us from Our Own Dangerous Behaviors (such Seat Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1477225-are-laws-that-protect-us-from-our-own-dangerous.
“Are Laws That Protect Us from Our Own Dangerous Behaviors (such Seat Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1477225-are-laws-that-protect-us-from-our-own-dangerous.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Are laws that protect us from our own dangerous behaviors (such seat belt or helmet) morally acceptable

Applying Relevant Legal Theories and Moral Perspectives

Some would argue that along with the privilege to operate a vehicle, a responsibility to obey all rules set forth by lawmakers necessarily follows and that helmet and seat belt laws are not considered victimless.... Some would argue that along with the privilege to operate a vehicle, a responsibility to obey all rules set forth by lawmakers necessarily follows and that helmet and seat belt laws are not considered victimless.... The study predicted that if the UK were to enact compulsory seat belt legislation, deaths incurred by those...
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Why car seat belts should be a law

In 1973, a National Health Survey revealed that one in every 50 persons suffered from motor related health injuries (Roberston, 1976) while in 2000, 8145 passenger vehicle occupants were involved in fatal motor… These statistics are not directly related to accidents caused due to non-compliance of seat belt laws.... It is generally believed that wearing seat belts is the easiest way of reducing injuries and deaths occurrences but research suggests Research suggests that making seat belt use a primary offense does not result in reduced death rates, enforcement of law to wear seat belts in the car can adversely influence behavior, and risk is an individual factor, hence enforcement of seat belts only affect the external behavior posing higher risk to others including cyclists, pedestrian and other drivers....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Why there sould be helmet laws for motorcycle operators and passangers

In recent years, as the publics attention has been drawn more to the subject of helmet laws, there has been a heated debate on the legislation of such laws for motorcycle operators and passengers.... In order to achieve the goal and do so, helmet laws should be legislated.... Many oppose the legislation of these laws, but from my personal experience, having been involved in a motorcycle accident and saved by wearing a helmet, I know it is imperative to wear a helmet while driving a motorcycle....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Role of Seat Belts in Road Safety

However, the number of car accident deaths has reduced from around 5,500 per year in the mid 1980s to fewer than 2,000 in 2010 as per the Royal Society for the Prevention… One of the important causes of road casualities is lack of seat belt wearing.... Too many people are still ignoring the warning and if drivers and passengers adhered to the seat belt policy approximately 300 lives could be saved every year in the United The UK government tries to enforce the seat belt policy which was first implemented in 1983 (BBC News, 2009)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Mandatory Helmets while Skiing

Wearing a helmet is not.... However, skiing is also quite dangerous.... The truth is that skiing is often a very dangerous activity.... It is a very easy and inexpensive plan which would have excellent results in helping people to be safer on dangerous hills.... It is a small cost to ensure the safety of our children....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Bicycle Helmet Safety

l (2009) on urban primary school kids in UK, 136 out of 270 kids admitted to never wearing helmet when riding a bicycle.... l (2011) further noted that 90 percent of kids of between 3-5 years did own a bicycle but only 20 percent of them possessed a helmet.... This research paper seeks to establish how helmet wearing in children reduces the number of bicycle related injuries.... l (2009) was aimed at assessing self –wearing helmet practice in young children of ages of 8-13 years....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Why You Should Wear Your Seat Belt

seat belt or Air BagsAccording to the study of Alic, Miklos, and Imre (2011), the use of the seat belt and airbags are considered to be one of the most important safety devices, but studies show that the seat belts are more effective safety devices than airbags.... This paper "Why You Should Wear Your seat belt" focuses on the significance of seat belts while driving as a measure to prevent injuries and death in car accidents.... The report illustrates no belt use in the driving is 2....
5 Pages (1250 words) Literature review

Motorcycle Helmet Laws

In countering these deaths, many states enforced helmet laws, but the withdrawal of the economic incentive led to their repeal.... hellip; This research tells that the arguments against the importance of helmet laws include that crashes only affect the rider, helmet use raises health concerns and rider training is more useful.... Helmets limit the rights and the freedoms of individuals, helmet use encourages risk-taking and failing to use helmets is comparable to other risky behaviors which have not been restricted by the government....
18 Pages (4500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us