StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Is social inequality meritocratic - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
It is difficult to say whether social inequality is meritocratic or not without any base of knowledge, i.e. without any information about the issue. In this work I'm going to present points of view of three outstanding scholars: Melvin Tumin, Karl Marx and Max Weber and produce my own vision of the subject.
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.3% of users find it useful
Is social inequality meritocratic
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Is social inequality meritocratic"

Download file to see previous pages

One motive for the incredible persistence of social hierarchies is that they are reinforced by ideology, cultural viewpoints that cause and maintain the interest of definite categories of people and justify stratification. Naturally, ideology takes the structure of developing cultural patterns that are confirmed directly and indirectly in accordance with a disproportionate distribution of resources and rights to definite categories of people. Melvin M. Tumin studied social stratification and inequality and summarized: functional justification is similar to class system; we act according to certain patterns or sets of ideas.

Social stratification can in fact cause demotivation of people, those who are deprived of their rights might also be demotivated. Also Tumin states that social stratification depends on relations of power and distribution of power in society. "The main functional necessity explaining the universal presence of stratification is precisely the requirement faced by any society of placing and motivating individuals in the social structure. As a functioning mechanism a society must somehow distribute its members in social positions and induce them to perform the duties of these positions.

It must thus concern itself with motivation at two different levels: to instill in the proper individuals the desire to fill certain positions, and, once in these positions, the desire to perform the duties attached to them" (Tumin, 1953, socserv2.mcmaster.ca, par. 5). Social inequality systems' purpose is to provide the privileged classes with the political power needed to obtain recognition and supremacy of an ideology which rationalizes the status quo, whatever it may be, as "logical," "natural" and "morally right.

This way, social inequality systems are those of fundamentally conservative influences in the societies in which they are established. So Tumin states that meritocracy is based on the importance of one's status and occupation. Social-conflict perspective shows that, rather than benefiting society as a whole, social stratification guarantees that some people get advantage at the expense of others. Karl Marx states that the two main social classes match to the two basic relationships people have to the resources of production.

People can own property or they can work for others. In industrialized class models, the capitalists (or the) manage plants, which use the manual labor of workers (the proletariat). Work that consists mostly of manual labor is known as "blue-collar" work whereas work that contains middle-management office jobs is known as "white-collar" jobs. Marx believed that social disparity was dangerous for society. Marx gives a vivid contraposition of those two classes and suggests that social inequality is exactly meritocratic, since 'white-collar' class is more privileged and comprises elite, which exploits proletarians, or people who have no own property.

The inner merit of person from higher class is that he or she was born in such family and belongs to bourgeoisie. Marx's and Weber's concepts are similar in many aspects, so the author decided to compare them. The idea of class and class struggle does not occupy as significant a role in Weber as in Marx. In Weber's opinion, the rising speed of bureaucracy in all organizations is an unavoidable of the

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Is social inequality meritocratic Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1501210-is-social-inequality-meritocratic
(Is Social Inequality Meritocratic Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1501210-is-social-inequality-meritocratic.
“Is Social Inequality Meritocratic Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1501210-is-social-inequality-meritocratic.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Is social inequality meritocratic

School's Role in Socialization by Durkheim and Parsons

This essay analyses the similarities and differences between their ideas on education and inequality.... This essay analyses the similarities and differences between their ideas on education and inequality.... hellip; Both Durkheim and Parsons believe that education inspires social solidarity.... Therefore, all of them agree on the important role the school plays in the social system.... oth Durkheim and Parsons believe that education inspires social solidarity....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

America after Meritocracy by Chris Hayes

This is because it was marred by a myriad of social malpractices, ranging from inequality to corruption.... This further broadened the social gap, making inequality a social norm.... When the public ignores this inequality, the top brass are left susceptible to failure, including corruption and social isolation.... inequality is the root of almost all injustices in the society.... Hayes has built a reputation for his role in political, economical, and social criticism....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Meritocracy, Inequality, and Mobility

Initially, meritocracy was unheard of since people used to be given jobs on basis of their parents achievements or the persons looking… In the UK, meritocracy has been practiced at different levels, however, rules and regulations which have been enacted make it easy for all to be included in the education system as well as the equal opportunities for education making it social mobility has become an issue even in politics since each and every policy now deals with whether it will allow people to change or rise from the current situation (Marshall, G....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Factors Influencing Childs Education

ducation is supposed to be meritocratic in nature and the means through which people break through the cumbersome social barriers of class and privilege.... Is it true that education is meritocratic and based upon the notion that it allows people to advance, progress, and move forward in life?... Home to some of the best private/independent schools in the world such as Eaton College and the Exeter School, the UK is a country heavily stratified by economic and social forces....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Lower the college tuition

Education is supposed to be meritocratic in nature and that means that people are accepted into universities and colleges across this country based on their abilities and not the wealth of their parents.... Education is the way in which people break through social barriers like class and privilege.... The expansion of education in the past two hundred years in the United States is an incredible advance which has supposed increased social equality and made society a better place....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Singapore Educational System - Issues of Equality

From the paper "The Singapore Educational System - Issues of Equality" it is clear that the teachers have to make sure that all individuals within the institution gain the required educational achievements despite their differences through the meritocratic system of sophistication.... he Singapore education scheme offers equality in various ways, although the meritocratic education also fails to address certain issues mainly, the issue where scholars with dissimilar social backgrounds go through teaching in a disparate manner....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Education, Meritocracy, and Employability Issues in the United Kingdom

This (free education) was geared towards the creation of a meritocratic society in the United Kingdom by giving all individuals an equal chance to attain any employment goals of their choice.... The issue of the provision of free and compulsory education through the implementation of the various Acts as seen in the introductory section of this article is what Weber, in his Theory of social Class refers to as 'communal action'.... This, in other words, means that individuals in a given place, despite their differences for instance in social classes, they will still have a feeling that in one way or the other, they have something in common....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us