StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Humanity by Immanuel Kant - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
On the other hand, this duty must always be considered as an obligation that does not cause harm to another person. For this reason, Constant is convinced that truthfulness must be followed in the case…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.8% of users find it useful
Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Humanity by Immanuel Kant
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Humanity by Immanuel Kant"

Truthfulness as a Duty What argument does Constant give to refute Kant’s position that it is always wrong to lie?Similar to Kant, Constant admits that truthfulness can be regarded as a duty. On the other hand, this duty must always be considered as an obligation that does not cause harm to another person. For this reason, Constant is convinced that truthfulness must be followed in the case if it does not harm another person. Kants strict requirement to comply with the truthfulness everywhere and in everything makes the existence of society impossible.2. Why is it always our duty to answer truthfully a question that we cannot avoid answering?

Truthfulness is a duty. Moreover, truthfulness must be respected even in those cases where we cannot avoid answering. This is due to the fact that a man who speaks the truth should not be seen as responsible for the consequences resulting from his/her honest answer. The harm caused to a person as a result of the truthfulness does not impose any moral or legal responsibility to the one who has told the truth, because in this case we are talking about an accident.3. Why is it redundant to define a lie as falsehood that harms another?

This is due to the fact that a lie “always hurts another; and if not another man, at least man kind in general by making the source of all right useless” (Kant and Kroeger 12). It makes no sense to define a lie as the falsehood that harms another because causing harm is the very essence of the lie. 4. In what kind of situation could a lie told to save an innocent friend be punishable under civil law? Despite the fact that in some cases, a lie is seen as an opportunity to save a loved one, however the consequences can be quite severe, including the tragic ones.

In particular, if someone in an attempt to save the life of his friend lied to a murderer about the location of his friend and yet the murder has happened, this person may be punishable under civil law. In this case, the person who told the lie is responsible for the consequences. 5. How does Constants argument rest on a confusion between an act that harms another and act wrongs another? Constants believes that in some cases, truthfulness may harm another person, but in fact truthfulness cannot cause harm because it is a formal duty.

Harm can be caused only by an accident (casus) to which the veracity is irrelevant. For this reason, truthfulness should be considered as an unconditional duty in any situation.Work CitedKant, Immanuel, and A. E. Kroeger. “Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Humanity.” The Journal of Speculative Philosophy 7.2 (1873): 14-19. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Humanity by Assignment”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1695833-concerning-a-pretended-right-to-lie-from-motives-of-humanity-by-immanuel-kant
(Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Humanity by Assignment)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1695833-concerning-a-pretended-right-to-lie-from-motives-of-humanity-by-immanuel-kant.
“Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Humanity by Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1695833-concerning-a-pretended-right-to-lie-from-motives-of-humanity-by-immanuel-kant.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Humanity by Immanuel Kant

Immanuel Kants Universalizability Test

The article takes a deeper look at immanuel kant's Universalizability Test which is used to make a judgment of the moral character of a given maxim such that if an individual cannot imagine the possibility of a particular thing by all humans then to them it is an impossibility.... kant mentions that a maxim that cannot be universalized consistently is 'practically irrational'.... kant's argument demonstrate that the act cannot be whatsoever universalized, its motivations are misplaced hence cannot be done by people under similar conditions all over the world....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Ideas of Emmanuel Kant

("immanuel kant", 2006).... immanuel kant.... immanuel kant.... For Emmanuel kant,knowledge is constructed by the mind, not passively derived through the senses; in other words, the mind shapes the world.... ne of kant's works, the Critique of Pure Reason, is an attempt to answer the problems of the nature of knowledge—what it is and how it is obtained.... hellip; kant looks at the relationship between a priori knowledge, or knowledge based on reason alone, and a posteriori knowledge, or knowledge gained from the world....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Has humanity progressed

We will analyze the changes shown by the humanity in light of all several ophical theories which includes the Leviathan theory by Thomas Hobbes, Discourse on Inequality by Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Enlightenment by immanuel kant, and the German ideology by Karl Marx.... The advancement in technology has facilitated the lives of the human beings and they have obtained education to explore new possibilities in the field of… Although there is little doubting the fact that the humans have progressed till now, I believe that humanity has not progressed, in fact we have gone from bad to worse....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Liberal International Thought Since Immanuel Kant

hellip; According to the report, immanuel kant is one of the most influential philosophers of the liberal tradition whose ideas have remained relevant in the contemporary world.... This paper seeks to show that liberal international thought has not really moved on since immanuel kant through a study of liberalism in the contemporary world.... The discussion above has sought to show that liberal international thought has not really moved on since immanuel kant through a study of liberalism in the contemporary world....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

"Concerning a Pretended Right to Lie from Motives of Humanity" by Immanuel Kant

concerning a pretended right to lie from motives of humanity.... Additionally, there is no individual with the The Pretended Right from motives of humanity to Lie Affiliation According to Constant, it is not always wrong to tell a lie.... Hence, people have an obligation to tell the truth, but the duty is towards an individual with the right to truth.... Hence, people have an obligation to tell the truth, but the duty is towards an individual with the right to truth....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Immanuel Kants Theory of Beneficence

The paper "immanuel kant's Theory of Beneficence" describes that in Kant's view, it is our unconditional duty to use sympathy as a tool for promoting rational and active benevolence through the will to share in the feelings of others, and not merely being receptive.... As a principle of humanity, therefore, it is one's duty to contribute to the happiness of others.... hellip; In my opinion, kant's view of beneficence is plausible.... kant puts it where one can, beneficence is a duty (kant 53) and should be done without self-interest or another motive of vanity....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Jeremy Bentham and Immanuel Kant on Suicide

The "Jeremy Bentham and immanuel kant on Suicide" paper states that when it comes to labeling suicide as an immoral act, the more adequate argument actually belongs to Bentham, no matter how profound Kant's philosophy is....   The 18th-century philosophers Jeremy Bentham and immanuel kant constructed ethical principles that determined the rightness or wrongness of suicide.... The act of suicide is not moral based on the ethical principles authored by Jeremy Bentham and immanuel kant....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Analysis of The Retributive Theory of Punishment by Immanuel Kant

"Analysis of The Retributive Theory of Punishment by immanuel kant" paper discusses the contradiction between Kant's ethical and political philosophy, legal and political theory concerning punishment, and Kant's incomprehension of deterrence theory of punishment.... How is it possible to justify a punishment concerning a particular type of crime?... The answer and other aspects revolving around this question will be discussed with the help of the article by kant, where he expounds on the retributive nature of punishment....
5 Pages (1250 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us