StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Legal Status of Comfort Letters in South Africa - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay declares that a comfort letter is generally defined as a document issued by a parent company which is primarily aimed to encourage a lending institution to issue credit to another company which is usually a subsidiary of the maker or issuer…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
Legal Status of Comfort Letters in South Africa
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Legal Status of Comfort Letters in South Africa"

 A comfort letter is generally defined as a document issued by a parent company which is primarily aimed to encourage a lending institution to issue credit to another company which is usually a subsidiary of the maker or issuer (Block, et. al, 2004). In the case of Kleinworth Benson v. Malaysia Mining Corporation Berhad 1 WLR 379 at 391 (1989), the court held that “letters of comfort denotes a document under which comfort is given to the leader by the assumption not of legal responsibility but of moral responsibility only”. As such, comfort letters generally are not indented to be legally binding. The use of comfort letters is becoming widespread in the commercial lending world. It is now commonly used in countries like the United States of America, the United Kingdom, and Australia. However, these countries do not have specific statutory law/s pertaining to the formation and the enforceability of comfort letters but they rely on the universally accepted general principles of obligations and contracts and of the common laws. It is hereby submitted that the answer to the question of when do comfort letters create an enforceable obligation to the maker or issuer depends on the factors or circumstances surrounding the creation, the contents, and the conditions of the acceptance of the comfort letter as will be discussed in this work. The legal status of comfort letters in other countries like South Africa is still a relatively new subject of legal research and there is not an abundance of case law in commercial lending pertaining to the use of comfort letters in that country. In the absence of abundant common and statutory laws that will hold the legal status of comfort letters in South Africa, it is presumed that South Africa also follows the universally accepted general principles of obligations and contracts and the common laws in dealing with comfort letters, South Africa being a part of international community that recognizes these principles. The essence of comfort letters is to encourage a lending institution (i.e. potential creditor) to enter into a legally binding transaction with the subsidiary company (i.e. potential debtor) while attempting to avoid liability should the subsidiary fails to perform (Block, et. al, 2004, quoting from the case of LaSalle Bank National Association v. Citicorp Real Estate [2003] WL 21671812). With this context, courts generally view comfort letters unenforceable and the maker or issuer assumes no obligation as comfort letters are not intended to be legally binding obligations (Block, et. al, 2004). The enforceability of comfort letters depends upon the factors established in the following decided cases: 1) Kleinwort Benson Limited v. Malaysia Mining Corporation Berhad 1 WLR 379 at 391 (1989); 2) Banque Brussels Lambert SA v. Australian National Industries Limited 21 NSWLR 502 (1989); and 3) Gate Gourmet Australia Pty Limited (in liq) ACN 089 374 562 v. Gate Gourmet Holding AG and Ors NSWSC 149 (2004). In the Kleinworth Benson case, the court said that in order to determine whether the comfort letter created an enforceable obligation on the part of the maker or issuer, legal construction of the words or language used in the comfort letter should be made. If the words or language strongly suggest that the comfort letter is promissory in nature which is evident on the face of the letter itself, the maker or issuer is obliged to perform an obligation under the comfort letter. In this case, the court held that the comfort letter is not enforceable because the terms only represented it was the “practice” of the company to provide financial support and with no indication in the letter that the policy would continue in the future (Gurney, et. al). The Banque Brussels’ decision took a more liberal approach by saying that in addition to the terms of the letter, one must consider the factual matrix surrounding the creation of the comfort letter (Gurney, et. al). Simply stated, if the maker or issuer does not intend to be binded by the comfort letter, he or she must include a disclaimer or a clear statement on the face of the letter that he or she does not intend to give rise to any legal obligation whatsoever. Otherwise, in the absence of the disclaimer, the comfort letter is intended to be legally enforceable. This view somehow was utilized by a court in deciding a case in 2002 when it held that the plaintiffs’ reliance on the comfort letters was unjustifiable because the disclaimer language expressly stated that they were ‘not to be used, circulated, quoted, or otherwise referred to for any purpose, including but not limited of the purchase or sale of securities” (Block, et. al, 2004, quoting from the case of Rotterdam Ventures, Inc. v. Ernst Young, [2002] 752 N.Y.S. 2d 746). However, the case of Gate Gourmet Australia Pty Limited decided in 2002 is a recent judgment of the Supreme Court of NSW in which the parties found themselves in court testing the validity of such letters against the propositions outlined by the leading authorities. For the first time since Banque Brussels cases, a letter of comfort was found to have given rise to enforceable obligation. In this case, the auditors of Gate Gourmet Holdings Pty Limited requested the Swiss parent company to provide a letter of support to the Australian Gate Gourmet group given its nominal capitalization and the fully drawn nature of its external facilities. Evidence suggested that the directors of Gate Gourmet Holdings Pty Limited were seeking support in order to be satisfied that the Gate Gourmet Australia was not trading while insolvent. The court held that the comfort letter was in nature promissory and binding based on the language used, “to meet the respective commitments as and when they fall due” that indicated an obligation of a recurrent and continuing kind. In short, it was found out that the primary purpose of the comfort letter was to induce other business persons to enter into a business transaction. Comfort letters by that nature, always contain promissory language (in the absence of a disclaimer), otherwise directors or subsidiaries would not be able to place any reliance on them. In that decision, Clayton Utz acted for the liquidator of a company which had the benefit of such a letter of comfort. In that case, the Supreme Court of NSW held that a letter of comfort that came into existence created a binding contract between, among others, the Australian trading arm of the foreign-owned Gate Gourmet Group (“Trading Company”) and the Swiss based parent company (Gurney, et. al). To summarize the stated facts, a comfort letter can give rise to a contractual obligation only if it is itself a contract. An agreement will be a contract only if it is concluded with the intentions of creating an obligation or obligations. It is the existence of this intention to create obligations which distinguishes a contract from any other agreement. Therefore, a comfort letter will be a contract only if it is proven that there was a common intention to create obligations. There are various pointers or factors which may be utilized to determine if a comfort letter is an enforceable contract. Some of these are: 1) the language of the comfort letter itself; 2) the sophistication of the parties; 3) oral representations; 4) the parties’ prior dealings; 5) whether or not the instrument is customarily viewed as enforceable in the particular trade or profession at issue; 6) The parties reason for using the letter of comfort; and 7) the role the letter of comfort played in the agreement (Block, et. al, 2004). The issue of the legal status of letters of comfort does not hold a definitive legal definition is South Africa. Similar to other jurisdictions, the formation and the enforceability of comfort letters in this country follow the bases of other countries as provided in this work. Works Cited AICPA Professional Liability Insurance Program, (2009). “CPA Comfort Letter to Lenders”. Retrieved April 8, 2009 from AICPA.org Block, et. al. (2004). “Comfort Letters: Casual Drafting Can Turn Into a Guarantee”. New York Law Journal. (Online). Retrieved on May 5, 2009 from Comfort Letter. (2009). In Investopedia ULC [Web]. Retrieved on April 7, 2009 from Gordon, K. (2006). “The Legal Status of letters of comfort in the South African Law”. Retrieved on April 7, 2009 from Goldman Judin Maisels Inc. (2009). Letters of Comfort [Brochure]. Johannesburg, South Africa: Gurney, et. al.“The Twilight Zone revisited – intragroup letters of comfort”. Clayton Utz. Retrieved on May 5, 2009 from NLB InterFinanz. (2000). “Legal Issues: What comfort are guarantees?”. Retrieved on May 5, 2009 from The Free Library. “Revival of the Letter of Comfort”. Retrieved on May 5, 2009 from Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Legal Status of Comfort Letters in South Africa Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1553424-legal-status-of-comfort-letters-in-south-africa
(Legal Status of Comfort Letters in South Africa Essay)
https://studentshare.org/social-science/1553424-legal-status-of-comfort-letters-in-south-africa.
“Legal Status of Comfort Letters in South Africa Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1553424-legal-status-of-comfort-letters-in-south-africa.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Legal Status of Comfort Letters in South Africa

The experiences of American Civil War Veterans in April 1865

The plantation elite, most of who were in the south ripping the benefits of slavery and forced labor in their tobacco, wheat and sugarcane plantation lacked the enthusiasm to relinquish their slave.... In 1861, south Carolina alongside ten other Southern states wrote to the federal government declaring their intention to secede from the continental USA.... Slavery was central in the American civil war since the south remained adamant to relinquish their slaves even after Lincoln issued the historic Emancipation Proclamation after provoking his presidential powers....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

The Horrors that Experienced During the American Civil War

Harriet Beecher Stowe Name Class Section Number Harriet Beecher Stowe It was God's will that this nation - the North as well as the south - should deeply and terribly suffer for the sin of consenting to and encouraging the great oppressions of the south; that the ill-gotten wealth, which had arisen from striking hands with oppression and robbery, should be paid back in the taxes of war; that the blood of the poor slaves, that had cried so many years from the ground in vain, should be answered by the blood of the sons from the best hearthstones through all the free states; that the slave mothers, whose tears nobody regarded, should have with them a great company of weepers, North and south -… Rachels weeping for their children and refusing to be comforted; that the free states that refused to listen when they were told of lingering starvation, cold, deprivation, and barbarous cruelty, as perpetrated on the slave, should have lingering starvation, cold, hunger, and cruelty doing its work among their own sons, at the hands of these slave-masters, whose sins our nation had connived” - Harriet Beecher Stowe (Charles Stowe and Lyman Stowe, Harriet Beecher Stowe: The Story of Her Life, 192)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Islamic Sharia Law in Present Day Nigeria

Through the activities of missionaries and Islamic traders from North africa, Islam began to spread slowly in this area.... Whether devout or not, the rulers benefited from the opportunities associated with Islam: the wealth of the transSaharan trade, the spread of ideas from North africa, and the ability to forge diplomatic relations with Muslim rulers elsewhere.... The conflict started with the advent of British rule, when the Muslims started feeling unsecured with a disrupted legal system because Nigerian Muslims particularly those of North were not in a position to tolerate any obstruction in between them and the 'Sharia' but at the same time they were bound to follow the legal system according to which the Sharia courts came under the supervision of Europeans probably the Christians....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Slavery in Colonial America

The prime area for slaves was on the west coast of africa called the Sudan.... Slavery has become one of the most intriguing periods in American history.... While most people associate slavery with the southern half of the country during the early nineteenth century, few know that slavery has been a stain on America's fabric since the colonists first settled on America's shores....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Uniqueness Of African-American History

Clare and Irene were childhood friends who get together after a long time sharing their bitter experiences of being born as Negroes, denied basic rights, try to find out comfort and consolation each other.... The novel mainly focuses on the 'passing' of the members of one class to that of the other by the illusion that this 'pass' will bring tremendous changes to their life and social status....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Dutchtown High School

This essay talks about Dutchtown High School which is a public school that was started back in 2002 as an unincorporated area of Ascension.... The school is located within the Ascension Parish school board.... Alongside the school, several other schools were started in the area by the same organization....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Islamic Sharia Law in Present Day Nigeria

Through the activities of missionaries and Islamic traders from North africa, Islam began to spread slowly in this area.... Whether devout or not, the rulers benefited from the opportunities associated with Islam: the wealth of the trans-Saharan trade, the spread of ideas from North africa, and the ability to forge diplomatic relations with Muslim rulers elsewhere.... he conflict started with the advent of British rule when the Muslims started feeling unsecured with a disrupted legal system because Nigerian Muslims particularly those of North was not in a position to tolerate any obstruction in between them and the 'Sharia' but at the same time they were bound to follow the legal system according to which the Sharia courts came under the supervision of Europeans probably the Christians....
14 Pages (3500 words) Term Paper

Stowe about the Horrors of Slavery and the American Civil War

The slavery of the south was intolerable to Stowe.... This essay discusses the horrors of slavery and the American Civil War described by Harriet Beecher Stowe.... She has reflected this in her book “Uncle Tom's Cabin” craving to ignite a passion for resistance in powerless Blacks....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us