StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Comparing the Ideas of Jane Jacobs and Oscar Newman - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Comparing the Ideas of Jane Jacobs and Oscar Newman" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in the comparison of the ideas of Jane Jacobs and Oscar Newman. There is proximity of urban neighborhoods to cities and cities’ tendency to be high-crime areas…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.8% of users find it useful
Comparing the Ideas of Jane Jacobs and Oscar Newman
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Comparing the Ideas of Jane Jacobs and Oscar Newman"

Essay Topic: Compare and contrast the ideas of Jane Jacobs and Oscar Newman in their approach to safety and security in urban neighbourhoods and centres. Which do you think is the most appropriate? Justify your answer. The close proximity of urban neighbourhoods to cities and cities’ tendency to be high crime areas has engaged criminologists and theorists in discussions about maintaining urban safety and security (Marzbali et al, 2011). Jacobs and Newman both made valuable contributions to the idea of urban safety by connecting crime control as well as the fear of crime to urban design and the common activities manifested in daily living (Wekerle, 2000). The idea of defensible space originated out of the ideas of Jane Jacobs in 1961 and was further developed by Oscar Newman in 1973 (Greenberg et al, 1982). Both Jacobs and Newman ultimately argued in favour of creating boundaries in urban neighbourhoods for crime prevention strategies, although in slightly different ways. Jacobs is largely credited with articulating the “eyes on the street” theory of crime prevention in urban neighbourhoods, while Newman is credited with expanding upon Jacob’s theory and developing what has come to be known as defensible space (Carmona, et al, 2010, p. 151). Essentially, Jacobs argued that keeping our eyes on the street provides a significant remedy for keeping our streets and neighbourhoods safer and more secure. Newman used the term defensible space to expound upon Jacob’s theory and argued that the infrastructure of urban areas with high-rise buildings created danger because people who occupied these places were helpless to defend, identify, see their entire property. Eradicating fear of crime and prevention crime was therefore solved by creating boundaries that segregated the streets from the streets (Carmona, et al, 2010). Thus both Jacobs and Newman contributed to the theory that urban design is a valuable method for reducing the fear of crime and preventing crime in urban neighbourhoods by recognising and responding to the idea of creating boundaries between areas that were in close proximity to high crime areas: the city. Jacobs (1961) proposed that by increasing neighbourhood participation at the street level would help residents to control their surrounding streets. The rationale for this theory was that the more eyes directed toward the streets would act as a deterrent to crime. Jacobs (1961) argued that placing bright lights on streets is not enough unless there are eyes trained on the area. She argued that eyes are the primary method for crime prevention and cautioned that crimes to occur in well light areas while crimes will not occur in a dark area that is well attended, such as in a “darkened theatre” (Jacobs, 1961, p. 42). Jacobs (1961) explained that crimes: Virtually never occur in darkened theaters where may people and eyes are present. Street lights can be like that famous stone that falls in the desert where there are no ears to hear. Does it make a noise? Without effective eyes to see, does a light case light? Not for practical purposes (p. 42). Streets for the purpose of keeping a watchful eye are figurative expressions for Jacobs (1961). Streets can mean any means by which citizens get from one location to another and thus streets according to Jacobs (1961) include elevators, corridors or any kind of thoroughfare in modern high-rise buildings which are described as “derivatives of Radian City” (p.42). Elevators, corridors and other thoroughfares in and around high-rise buildings are streets because their main purpose is “eliminate streets on the ground and permit the ground to become deserted parks” in areas where “the tree was stolen” (Jacobs, 1961. p. 42). These substitutive streets create dangers in that they are accessed by residents who may or may not know one another. Moreover these substitutive streets link these buildings to the actual streets and therefor the public at large. These substitutive streets are more dangerous than public streets because they do not have the watchful eyes that public streets have and thus “lack the checks and inhibitions exerted by eye-policed city streets” (Jacobs, 1961, p. 43). Atlas (1991) agrees with Jacobs assessment of the dangers of urban living in what Jacobs (1961) termed the “blind-eyed” streets (p. 43). According to Atlas, criminals have the same ideas about these substitutive streets and are more inclined to use areas that are hidden from public view further segregated from public and police detection and apprehension by the presence of fences, walls and other physical barriers. Deterrence in these areas works well when there are watchful doormen, elevator attendants and other persons who serve as look-out personnel (Atlas, 1991). In other words, Jacob’s (1961) idea of eyes on the street translates to mean increased human activities in the areas of the corridors, pathways, elevators and other means by which residents and strangers alike have access to high-rise buildings or urban neighbourhoods. Thus Jacobs (1961) advocated that with a varying degree of people on streets or in places accessible by the public, at different times which essentially took place during day time, indicated that eyes on the street had a deterrent effect. One only had to take into account that fewer crimes took place during the day. This is not because of lighting, but primarily because there is always someone present and with this means eyes were always watching, making detection and apprehension more probable. For Jacobs (1961) this meant that ironically, larger and busy city streets were safer because the increased activities on the street acted as a form of common and ad hoc form of policing in urban areas where individuals are merely conducting their daily activities. Jacobs’ (1961) eyes on the street theory provide an important doctrinal basis for Newman’s idea of defensible space. Jacobs (1961) essentially argued that ordinary citizens can inadvertently contribute to crime prevention in much the same way as conscious policing. Similarly, Newman (1973) argued that housing design may: Release latent attitudes in tenants which allow them to assume behaviour necessary to the protection of their rights and property (p. xii). Newman (1973) also argues in a way that is similar to Jacobs (1961) theory of eyes on the street that, maintaining defensible spaces motivates occupiers to perform a “significant policing function, nature to their daily routine and activities” and this would serve a significant deterrent “against anti-social behaviour” (p. xii). Newman’s (1973) defensible space theory is similar to Jacobs’ eyes on the street theory by definition. Newman (1973) defines defensible space as: A surrogate term for the range of mechanisms – real and symbolic barriers, strongly defined areas of influence, and improved opportunities for surveillance – that combine to bring an environment under the control of its residents (p. 3). The only discernible difference in the theories of Jacobs (1961) and Newman (1973) is that Jacobs focused attention on how urban living can foster and create criminal activities and how increasing activities in urban living can counter criminal activities. Newman (1973) more directly focused attention on how urban living can be an important tool in crime prevention. Newman (1973) essentially identified four opportunities in urban living for preventing criminal activities. First, the “physical environment” itself provide “zones of territorial influence” (Newman, 1973, p. 50). These zones automatically engaged citizens in a way that created opportunities for surveillance and the conscious creation of boundaries. While this is similar to Jacobs’ (1961) eyes on the street theory, Newman (1973) expands on Jacobs’ (1961) by adding that keeping one’s garden and building tidy would also signal the constant presence of the occupier and thus would act as a deterrent to crime. In other words, Newman (1973) goes farther than Jacobs (1961) by adding that a neighbourhood or residence that was physically neglected could attract criminals and thus increase the chances of criminal activity. Newman’s (1973) second opportunity for crime prevention in urban living is expressed in terms of opportunities for surveillance and is thus very similar to Jacobs’ (1961) eyes on the street theory. Here Newman (1973) like Jacobs (1961) directs the focus on how occupants of urban dwelling places can consciously serve as look-outs. What distinguishes Newman’s (1973) theory from Jacob’s (1961) theory is that Jacobs (1961) appears to advocate for unconscious observations while Newman (1973) advocates for deliberate and conscious observations of the neighbourhood. In other words, Jacobs (1961) argues for increasing activities with the appearance of watching, while Newman (1973) argues for deliberately keeping an eye out on the neighbourhood. Newman’s (1973) third opportunity for crime prevention in urban living is: ...the capacity of design to influence the perception of a project’s uniqueness, isolation and sigma (p. 50). Thus, Newman (1973) like Jacobs (1961) identified the way that urban designs may be such that they appealed to criminals. Like Jacobs (1961), Newman suggested that how residents acted in these areas could also act as a deterrent or may encourage criminal activities. For instance when residents were inactive, their neighbourhoods could act as crime magnets. However, when residents were active, criminals would perceive the chances of detection and apprehension were higher and thus committing crimes in these areas were too risky. In other words, both Jacobs (1961) and Newman (1973) recognized that the physical characteristics of neighbourhoods could be used by criminals to increase their activities and recognizing this, residents could safeguard against this by minimising the appeal of their residence as crime magnets. This would be accomplished by surveillance and maintenance (Newman, 1973) and increased activity (Jacobs, 1961). Newman’s (1973) fourth opportunity for crime prevention is described as: the influence of geographical juxtaposition with ‘safe zones’ on the security of adjacent areas (p. 50). Like Jacobs (1961) Newman (1973) proposes that increased activities of people in the narrow confines of the neighbourhood in a way that mirrors the activities of the busy city creates safer urban living. For Newman, it is the physical design or urban dwelling places that contribute to criminal activities. In particular Newman (1973) argued that: ...the physical form of the urban environment is possibly the most cogent ally the criminal has in his victimisation of society (p. 2). It can therefore be argued that both Jacobs (1961) and Newman (19730 recognized that residents of urban neighbourhoods could contribute to neighbourhood safety and security by creating a community in which the perceptions were that residents were always on the look-out for outsiders and criminal behaviour. Newman (1973) merely added to and not detracted from Jacobs’ (1961) eyes on the street theory. Newman (1973) added the dimension of conscious surveillance and neighbourhood up-keep to Jacobs’ (1961) active citizenship in the substitutive streets of the neighbourhood. Bibliography Atlas, R. 1991. “The Other Side of CPTED.” Architecture and Security, March: 63-66. Carmona, M.; Tiesdell, S.; Heath, T. and Oc, T. 2010. Public Places – Urban Spaces: The Dimensions of Urban Design. Oxford, UK: Architectural Press. Greenberg, S.W.; Rohe, W. M. and Williams, J. R. 1982. “Safety in Urban Neighbourhoods: A Comparison of Physical Characteristics and Informal Territorial Control in High and Low Crime Neighbourshoods.” Population & Environment, Vol. 5(3): 141-165. Jacobs, J. 1961. The Death and Life of Great American Cities. New York, NY: Random House. Marzbali, M.; Abdullah, A. and Razak, N. February 2011. “A Review of the Effectiveness of Crime Prevention by Design Approaches Towards Sustainable Development.” Journal of Sustainable Development, Vol. 4(1): 160-171. Newman, O. 1973. Defensible Space: People and Design in the Violent City. London, UK: Architectural Press. Wekerle, G. 2000. “From Eyes on the Street to Safe Cities [Speaking of Places]”. Places, Vol. 13(1): 44-49. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Comparison of the Ideas of Jane Jacobs and Oscar Newman in Their Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/agriculture/1588671-criminology-please-read-order-instructions
(Comparison of the Ideas of Jane Jacobs and Oscar Newman in Their Essay)
https://studentshare.org/agriculture/1588671-criminology-please-read-order-instructions.
“Comparison of the Ideas of Jane Jacobs and Oscar Newman in Their Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/agriculture/1588671-criminology-please-read-order-instructions.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparing the Ideas of Jane Jacobs and Oscar Newman

Life of Harriet Jacobs as a Slave Girl

Harriet jacobs For many, the 19th century United States meant slavery and abuse, and Harriet jacobs was no different.... jacobs was born to slave parents, which meant that she inherited their social status.... The early life of jacobs was not easy; her mother died when she was just 6 years old and she was forced into the care of her mother's mistress (Margaret Hornblow).... However, when jacobs reached the age of 8, Hornblow also died, and the ownership of Harriet as a slave was transferred to a girl of just 5 years old (the niece of Hornblow)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

New York City Zoning Regulations Vs The Death and Life of American Great Cities

jane jacobs, a writer and activist, in her book; The Death and Life of American Great Cities, criticizes the 20th century urban planning policy which she says lead to the decline of a number of cities in the neighborhoods in United States of America.... Considering the New York City zoning regulations, we can gauge that, some of these regulations reflect what jane jacobs is talking about in her book while some regulations do not reflect her ideas as we are going to discuss them....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Harriet Jacobs Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl

This story fulfils three narrative story themes and three rhetorical purposes; this article will provide examples to this effect in order to try and understand the message Jacob was trying to relay to her readers through her story (jacobs and Fleischner 53).... She achieves humanitarianism because the readers understand that Linda uses all the possible ways to get her freedom until she has no way out (jacobs and Fleischner 130).... Jacob, through her book, emphasizes traditional religious ideas....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Urban Thought of Jane Jacobs

This essay "The Urban Thought of jane jacobs" talks about one of the foremost stalwarts of urban formulation and a great exponent of the infrastructure of cities and the method the cities work or should work, that became a cult figure in the context of urban planning methods.... The method of jane jacobs is quite different from her contemporaries who indulge in the aspects of thought process.... jane jacobs' first book was published in 1960 named The Death and Life of Great American Cities and immediately was recognized as an assaultive figure who shattered all fundamental concepts of urban planning....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Oscar Newmans Defensible Space

This book review "oscar newman's Defensible Space " discusses policing of public spaces that is increasingly about controlling human actions by way of design, including a variety of SBD tools including surveillance equipment.... Based on the principal that pride of place and community cohesion has been replaced by social exclusion, fear of involvement and lack of trust amongst citizens within some local communities, newman's concept of Defensible Space sought to allocate large public spaces of land for collaborative development and design by the local residents themselves....
15 Pages (3750 words) Book Report/Review

Ideas of Jane Jacobs

From the paper "ideas of jane jacobs" it is clear that the NYT has an article on urban thinker and writer, Jane Jacobs, who just passed away.... jane jacobs, was a fearless, vocal critic and iconoclastic urban activist who wrote a compelling argument against the tabula rasa Robert Moses-style 'urban renewal' which was fashionable at the time?... jane jacobs wrote, 'The Economy of Cities' in which she pointed out that 'Poverty has no causes.... The jane jacobs Medals will be given each year to two living individuals who exemplify the following values and ideas (The Rockefeller Foundation): The question of why some countries remain poor and others are wealthy for decades....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Main Criticisms that Jane Jacobs Levelled at Urban Planning Thought at the Beginning of the 1960s

The author of this essay "The Main Criticisms that jane jacobs Levelled at Urban Planning Thought at the Beginning of the 1960s" describes her criticisms and its relevance nowadays.... jane jacobs also wrote extensively on the economies.... jane jacobs was particularly active in her role against the surge of urban renewal politics that emerged in the post-war period.... The critique that jacobs leveled at the renewal plan was normative in nature, emphasizing the values of the planning rather than the physical design....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Critical Analysis of The Death and Life of Great American Cities by Jane Jacobs

The "Critical Analysis of The Death and Life of Great American Cities by jane jacobs " paper revies book by jane jacobs that summarized gives true implementations that are to be carried out to enhance the overall performance of the cities.... Activists and intellects of the modern era such as jane jacobs have tried to prove to the world as to how many of the practices around the urbanization are flawed and require better solutions in order to protect the future of urbanization....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us