StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Michael Moore: Sicko - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
At its core, the traditional ideals of medical practise assumed the respect for all human life. This respect was manifested through the provision of medical care to anyone who needed it. Moore’s film highlights how the US health care system appears to have lost this respect for human life as shown through the failings within the different arms of the healthcare system…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
Michael Moore: Sicko
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Michael Moore: Sicko"

At its core, the traditional ideals of medical practise assumed the respect for all human life. This respect was manifested through the provision ofmedical care to anyone who needed it. Moore’s film highlights how the US health care system appears to have lost this respect for human life as shown through the failings within the different arms of the healthcare system. This point is brought out strongly by one of the characters in the documentary who asks: what happened to “we are the healthcare that leaves no one behind”?

In traditional medical practice there was a semblance to universal healthcare system funded and delivered by the governments in most countries. Pre 1900s doctors in the US were expected to provide free services to all their patients (PBS.org). This is one of the areas that “Sicko” exploits as a possible cause of the failings of the current American health care system. Moore juxtaposes the health maintenance organization (HMO) – led US health system to the socialised health systems in UK, France and Cuba.

The core difference between the socialized healthcare systems and the US HMO-led system is seen in terms of delivery. HMOs are private for profit organizations which are expected to provide a return on investment to their shareholders. Basic economics tells us that the incentives for HMOs will therefore be to maximize revenues and minimize costs, if they are to be efficient. To do this HMOs have developed several guidelines that have over time reduced access to adequate health care for a large number of Americans.

The documentary shows how HMOs are aggressively pursuing techniques to minimize their costs through: (1) setting of rigorous pre-qualification criteria that knocks the percentage of the population that would more likely be in need of greater medical care at a later age in their lives; (2) hiring medical reviewers whose job is specific job role is to deny patients medical care and; (3) hiring teams to scrutinize claims that have already been made with the aim to reclaiming their paid out monies.

Another major point that “Sicko” reveals about modern medical practices in comparison to the traditional is the former’s stronger inclination towards curative rather than preventive medical practices. With their huge financial resources, pharmaceutical companies have been successful in their lobbying for increased use of drugs from the government level to the HMOs. Moore informs us that there are up to four times more HMO and pharmaceutical company lobbyists than members of congress in Washington.

HMOs and pharmaceutical firms clearly support each other in making the health sector in the US unaffordable and the population highly dependent on their services. This goes against the traditional spirit of medical care that sought to keep people healthy and away from hospitals. Moore indirectly contrasts the curative focus of the American healthcare system with the preventive healthcare system in France and Cuba. In France physicians are able to prescribe long recuperation periods for their patients while in the US physicians prescribe more drugs.

Also we notice that the 9/11 heroes who went to Cuba are given less prescription in Cuba than what they were taking in the US. A highly successful preventive medicine campaign would most likely lower the market and margins for the pharmaceutical corporations. It is therefore not surprising that these large multinationals would lobby for curative medicine at the expense of preventive medicine. A third remarkable difference between traditional medical practices what Moore highlights is the behavior of medical practitioners.

In the past the physician’s fundamental role was to see that his/her patients get cured. Sicko shows us how doctors’ roles have changed especially the US. In the US, as Dr. Linda Pino testified in congress, HMOs hire some doctors whose primary duty is to use their medical expertise for the financial benefit of the insurer (Moore). In return the doctors are offered very lucrative financial incentives to keep them motivated towards denying patients medical care. In the past, medical doctors knew that they were getting into a profession that put them into contract with society.

As such a doctor’s role was closely allied to a sense of civic duty and a responsibility to shape their practice in response to the wellbeing of the society at large. However, the growth of consumerism, individualism and the corporation has had a big impact on the medical profession as well. In a highly capitalistic society like the US, doctors have also fallen into the social trend that encourages selfish accumulation of wealth at the expense of common good. The less individualistic societies have therefore been better able to preserve the traditional doctor’s role in society such that the doctor gets motivated by seeing a healthier community rather than a wealthier wallet.

To sum it all, “Sicko” reminds the American population that socialized medicine is not as bad as it has been portrayed. The HMO-mode of healthcare delivery needs to be re-thought and made more accessible especially to the underprivileged. Works Cited Moore, Michael. Sicko. Dog Eat Dog Films, 2007. Film. PBS.org. “PBS- Healthcare Crisis: Healthcare Timeline.” 26 Oct. 2011. Web. 26 Oct. 2011. 

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Michael Moore: Sicko Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Michael Moore: Sicko Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1434437-michael-moore-sicko
(Michael Moore: Sicko Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Michael Moore: Sicko Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1434437-michael-moore-sicko.
“Michael Moore: Sicko Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1434437-michael-moore-sicko.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Michael Moore: Sicko

Sicko by Michael Moore

There is also the basis of different HMO stories within this very movie, which is directed by none other than michael moore.... The documentary is an interesting one since it comes from the directorial stint of michael moore who is a name unmatched globally.... The movie has a typical michael moore style and aims to project the different shortcomings which are present within the very system nonetheless.... Some people have suggested that sicko has just touched the surface level of the problems which have haunted the very system within the country....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Experience of Illness and Disability

Hence, it is necessary to study the social influences that define individual concepts on This study analyses michael's case, where interview reveals a number of social perspectives on his view regarding health.... Through drawing from literature concepts and critically analysing the case study, specific aspects that will be covered are the lay health beliefs, illness behaviour, social support and practitioner-client interaction as they gradually progress in michael's illness narrative....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

The Revelations by Michael Moore in the Documentary Sicko

The revelations by michael moore in the documentary Sicko brings into perspective the sickening and repulsive realities of an American health care system that is bent on maximizing profits at the expense of the health of millions of Americans.... In essence, the documentary brings Movie Sicko of Affiliate The revelations by michael moore in the documentary Sicko brings into perspective the sickening and repulsive realities of an American health care system that is bent on maximizing profits at the expense of the health of millions of Americans....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Obamacare in Sicko

As michael moore said, if they are doing something that is better, then we should copy it.... In the essay “Obamacare in sicko” the author analyzes the movie “sicko” as one of the anti-America propaganda materials.... There is nothing “anti” about Obama's sentiments, he is merely trying to wake us all up to the fact that the American system is broken and needs fixing....
2 Pages (500 words) Movie Review

Sicko: Rhetorical Analysis

 This review discusses the film "Sicko" by michael moore.... “Sicko” a 2007 film by michael moore generally focuses on the American healthcare system, and with special emphasis on the health insurance system, and shows how this system affects the average American.... As a documentary set in contemporary times, sicko examines the state of the American healthcare system in comparison to other countries.... The United States, however, according to moore does not fall under the category of countries....
4 Pages (1000 words) Movie Review

Sicko by Michael Moore

The paper "Sicko by michael moore" tells that Sicko is a documentary film of 2007 which investigated health care issues in the United States.... moore compared universal health care systems in different countries… Former employees of insurance companies were also asked to give their views concerning cost-cutting initiatives, giving insurance company medical personnel a bonus.... According to one pharmacist interviewed by moore (moore film), pharmaceuticals are free of charge to every citizen in the UK....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

The Experiences of Health Illness and Disabilities

The main objective of the paper is to analyse the experiences of health illness and disabilities and thus link the case with adequate approaches, theories as well as concepts.... The paper explains four key concepts such as pain level, stigma, and conflict model and illness narrative.... hellip;  An illness can be recognized as a sickness....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Bowling for Columbine, Fahrenheit 9-11, and Sicko by Michael Moores

The review "Bowling for Columbine, Fahrenheit 9-11, and Sicko by michael moore's" describes informing and thought-provoking documentaries that examine issues central to the US.... hellip; michael moore is an American filmmaker, political activist, and author.... michael moore describes the magnitude of the use of guns by the Americans to kill one another in extraordinary frequency.... Moore has filmed a number of documentaries, including the notable Bowling for Columbine, Fahrenheit 9/11, and sicko....
5 Pages (1250 words) Movie Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us