StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Social Disorganization Theory - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
This article "Social Disorganization Theory" asserts that calls to the police are just like other official crime measures as they reflect two of the three major elements of the official crime counts familiar to the police: citizen willingness to report criminal behavior, and criminal behavior…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.4% of users find it useful
Social Disorganization Theory
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Social Disorganization Theory"

? Social disorganization theory Lecturer This paper seeks to review Barbara Warner and Glenn Pierce’s 1993 article “Reexamining social disorganization theory using calls to the police as a measure of crime, Criminology, 31”. This article looks at social disorganization theory using calls to the police in 60 Boston neighborhoods during 1980. The examined data, which are based on crime reports of the complainants instead of official reports by the police, gives room for further investigation of dissimilarities in the findings based on the data of victimization and official crime data. The rates of robbery, assault, and burglary are regressed on mobility, poverty, family disruption, racial heterogeneity, and structural density. The article has also addressed the interaction terms for poverty and mobility, poverty and heterogeneity, and mobility and heterogeneity are explored as well. The article’s result got from the study holds up the findings from recently carried out victimization studies and earlier studies of ecology using official crime counts. Structural density and family disruption, along with poverty and heterogeneity, are found to be significant ecological variables for mastering the crime rate distribution among neighborhoods (Warner and Glenn, 1993). In this article, social disorganization theory has been addressed intensively. The authors assert that social disorganization was among the prominent theories that explained crime in the earlier stages of this century. This is so because of the theory’s focus on the crime geological distribution of crime and the structural features of the neighborhoods that are related to the crime distribution. The article is also of the position that the approach of the ecology the study of crime fell, in the 1970s, out of trend. However, the ecology approach was replaced by more theories of social psychology. The authors say that several reasons for the social disorganization theory decline was in place, especially the devastating criticism that had a lot to do with the reliance of the research carried out on the official crime measures (Warner and Glenn, 1993). The article puts it that although many of the early social disorganization theory empirical examinations got support for its main ideas, the theories depended more on official crime measures (such as juvenile court referrals, arrests, and official counts of crime). It was argued in the article that the official measures of crime had a high likelihood to reflect biases in the official crime reactions because they were intended to reflect true measures of crime. This article viewed crime measures with particular skepticism when applied in relation to the communities’ characteristics. Non white and poor neighborhoods were suspected of being vulnerable especially to the inflated crime measures. The article also addresses the empirical support for criticisms provided by recent studies to this study (Warner and Glenn, 1993). Victimization data has also been reviewed in this article. The article asserts that the promise of more accurate social structural effects examination on crime and a social disorganization theory renewed interests came only with the beginning of victimization data. The findings in this article and the data collected enabled for counts of crime separately from any official crime responses, and research social disorganization theory examination using the collected data. The article also says that, though the studies of early victimization explored and examined cities instead of neighborhoods used for the majority of the studies carried out earlier, the findings of these studies nevertheless raised questions concerning conclusions based on the official data of crime. The results from the studies provided mixed support to the major social disorganization theory variables and questioned particularly the role of poverty. The article reports that Sampson (1985) detailed that mobility and racial composition were related positively to the total personal victimization and that the measures of poverty and income had weak and non significant effects when measures of family density and structure were controlled. The article reports more authors who have given mixed support of social disorganization theory through the use of victimization data. The article also says that variables such as poverty, mobility, and heterogeneity were significantly and positively related to the rates of burglary when they were the only equation predictors. The authors assert that poverty became insignificant when other variables were added to the equation. The article also documents that in an attempt to predict crime, heterogeneity and poverty had positive impacts when mobility was in the equation (Warner and Glenn, 1993). Other recent studies show that poverty affects positively rates of crime only when family structure is not included in the victimization data. The article addresses calls to the police as another crime measure providing avenue for social disorganization theory. Calls to the police as a measure of crime is based on service requests made to police. This has been used recently as a crime measure in various studies. The data used in this crime measure are based on definition of complainants of the events as coded by the operator 911. Contrary to the official crime counts, calls to the police are virtually unscreened and hence not susceptible to the biases of the police, this is the greatest asset of such data. The article also claims in its findings that such data provides the widest continuing net collection of data foe criminal events in town. The article also asserts that through the use of complainant event definition and not police report established definition, discretionary bias is avoided due to police decisions whether to file a report or not (Warner and Glenn, 1993). Summarily, the article asserts that calls to the police are just like other official crime measures as they reflect two of the three major elements of the official crime counts familiar to the police: citizen willingness to report criminal behavior, and criminal behavior. Police discretion as an element is however eliminated. This is because, as the article puts it, ecological studies have criticized the police discretion in the official counts of crime (Warner and Glenn, 1993). The article concludes that data on calls to the police are valuable for ecological theory studies. This is because call data can be aggregated easily to high level of neighborhood and are not biased by the unwillingness of the respondent to report certain kinds of incidents interviewers. References Warner, Barbara and Glenn Pierce, Reexamining social disorganization theory using calls to the police as a measure of crime: Criminology, 1993: 31. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Journal Article Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1469485-journal-article-review
(Journal Article Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1469485-journal-article-review.
“Journal Article Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1469485-journal-article-review.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Social Disorganization Theory

Social Structural Theories, Social Disorganization Theory and Cultural Deviance Theory

This research paper "Social Structural Theories, Social Disorganization Theory and Cultural Deviance Theory" focuses on one particular theory, labeling theory, that attempts to explain why youth are associated with criminal behaviors and/ or turn to delinquent lifestyles.... Cultural deviance theory asserts that conformity to the existing cultural norms of the society of lower-class results in crime.... his theory is associated with labeling theory, the rationale for choosing it (labeling theory), in that they both address a particular class of society and their beliefs....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Social Disorganization Theory: the Formulation of Crime

One popular and influential theory of crime is the Social Disorganization Theory, as embraced by Shaw and McKay (1969).... If this is based on the point of view of the Social Disorganization Theory, it must consider the issues of corruption, poverty and eventually the prevailing cultural background as potential explanations (Corbin, 1981).... Shaw and McKay found that the following conditions led to susceptibility to generate social disorganization....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper

Social Disorganization Qeustion and Answer

In its study, Social Disorganization Theory was developed from ecological theories.... herefore, social disorganization refers to the failure of the society in stages.... To understand this effect of social disorganization, gang theory approaches this problem by identifying cultural deviance or subcultural theories as factors contributing to social disorganization (Lander, 1954).... An urban ecology theory was A city develops when people gather together at a particular place with a wide range of activities....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

White-collar crime and criminal theories

he other theory, which explains white-collar crime, is the Social Disorganization Theory.... The key theorist who advanced the Social Disorganization Theory was Edwin Sutherland.... he Social Disorganization Theory is also based on the premise that social disorganization makes people break the law and disregard the rules in an organization.... Thus, Social Disorganization Theory contends that white-collar crime can be explained on the basis of disunity and lack of harmony in an organization (Krohn et....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

New Directions in Social Disorganization Theory

In addition, given that Mark had no Law Case Scenarios Scenario Mark's case can be well explained by the theory of ‘Social Disorganization Theory.... In addition, given that Mark had no father or siblings but only his mother and the criminal gangs, is sufficient evidence to say that his social environment compromised his rational thinking to opt joining the criminal gangs hence making this case scenario being in tandem and well explained by the Social Disorganization Theory'....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Social Disorganization and Strain Theories

Social Disorganization Theory describes the features of community involvement in the crime rate increase.... The behavior of Silvio and Armando is explainable in the light of Social Disorganization Theory.... As described by the Social Disorganization Theory, these communities contain homeless, poor, economically deprived and people with family issues, so Ariella's family was one among them.... The paper "social disorganization and Strain Theories" describes that Agnew's general strain theory describes strains as the reasons behind delinquent behavior....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

The Major Factor Influencing Delinquency

In the essay "OP-ED's position" the author describes that he agrees with OP-ED's position that the major factor that influences delinquency is poverty because Social Disorganization Theory suggests that poverty is an important ecological characteristic that can decrease collective efficacy and informal social control.... I agree with OP-ED's position that the major factor that influences delinquency is poverty because Social Disorganization Theory suggests that poverty is an important ecological characteristic that can decrease collective efficacy and informal social control....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Criminological Theory: Context and Consequences

Social Disorganization Theory, on the other hand, seeks to explicate why some communities are more prone to criminal activities in opposition to others.... Social Disorganization Theory, on the other hand, seeks to explicate why some communities are more prone to criminal activities in opposition to others.... n Social Disorganization Theory, various theories explain the concept.... Social Disorganization Theory, on the other hand, concentrates on social disorders that encourage crimes like racism, poverty, among others....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us