StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Case Brief: LONG ISLAND CARE AT HOME, LTD v. COKE, 551 US 158 (2007) - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Case Brief: LONG ISLAND CARE AT HOME, LTD v. COKE, 551 US 158 (2007) TITLE AND CITATION The title of the case is Long Island Care At Home, Ltd v. Coke. As can be observed from the title, the respondent is Evelyn Coke and the petitioner is Long Island Care at Home Ltd…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
Case Brief: LONG ISLAND CARE AT HOME, LTD v. COKE, 551 US 158 (2007)
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Case Brief: LONG ISLAND CARE AT HOME, LTD v. COKE, 551 US 158 (2007)"

Download file to see previous pages

Coke is a reversed and remanded case. The rule of this case further involved “filling of a statutory gap”, as per Justice Stephen Breyer’s opinion. Long Island Care had employed Coke as a healthcare attendant for its elderly home services and thus had an employer-employee relationship amid them. Eventually, Coke filed a case against the employer on the grounds of minimum wage and overtime benefits rights as per the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 (FLSA) (Cornell University Law School, “Supreme Court”).. Ruling in favor of Long Island, the petitioner, the District Court emphasized Coke to be exempted from the FLSA benefits being employed in the “companionship services” sector giving deference to the Department of Labor’s regulation 29 CFR Section 552.109(a). According to this regulation, employees paid by third-party agencies and not directly by their service users who might be families or households are categorized under the section for “companionship services” and thus, are exempted from the benefits of overtime and minimum wage offered by FLSA.

However, reversing the judgment of the District Court, the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit argued that the regulation of “companionship services” was actually a delusion of the statute and thus, was unenforceable on legal grounds. Hence, the regulation was not eligible to obtain lawful deference, either Chevron or Skidmore (OYEZ, “Long Island Care At Home, Ltd. V. Coke”). This particular ruling can be identified with reference to Auer v. Robbins, 519 U.S. 452 (1997) and Christensen v.

Harris County 529 U.S. 576 (2000) that had put a limit rendering Chevron deference and with reference to the case Gonzales v. Oregon, 546 U.S. 243 (2006) that criticized Skidmore deference (Administrative Law Review, “Cases on Deference”). However, the opinion of Justice Stephen Breyer stressed that the regulation, even if under the section “Interpretations”, was legitimate undergoing “full public notice-and-comment procedures”. Breyer argued that the case was a common illustration of defendants “filling a statutory gap” and thus, deference rendered by each court stating that the regulation was “valid and binding” was unlawful.

This made the regulation valid, remanding the judgment of the previous two courts (OYEZ, “Long Island Care At Home, Ltd. V. Coke”). ISSUES The main issues or questions from the case of Long Island Care At Home, Ltd V. Coke, indicated towards the treatment of statutory gap persisting in the regulations included under the section “Interpretations” and its applicability to prove Chevron deference [Chevron U. S. A. Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc.] (Cornell University Law School, “Chevron, U.S.A., Inc., Petitioner, v.

Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., et al. American Iron And Steel Institute, et al., Petitioners, v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., et al. William D. Ruckelshaus, Administrator, Environmental Prot”). The issues centered in the case also pointed on the possibility that the Second Circuit might have made a mistake in ruling the regulation as “unpersuasive” and thereby, exempting it from being applicable to Skidmore deference either (OYEZ, “Long Island Care At Home, Ltd. V. Coke”). DECISIONS The decision to the case had undergone three rounds of prosecutions.

First, in the District Court, it was ruled that the “third party regulation was valid and controlling”

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Case Brief: LONG ISLAND CARE AT HOME, LTD v. COKE, 551 US 158 (2007) Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1488630-case-brief-long-island-care-at-home-ltd-v-coke
(Case Brief: LONG ISLAND CARE AT HOME, LTD V. COKE, 551 US 158 (2007) Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1488630-case-brief-long-island-care-at-home-ltd-v-coke.
“Case Brief: LONG ISLAND CARE AT HOME, LTD V. COKE, 551 US 158 (2007) Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1488630-case-brief-long-island-care-at-home-ltd-v-coke.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Case Brief: LONG ISLAND CARE AT HOME, LTD v. COKE, 551 US 158 (2007)

Survey Done on Three Restaurants Services

Gary, R (2007) argues that the quality of produce is the key to successful entrepreneurship.... nbsp;… In this case, three restaurants were selected and a survey done on their services.... The paper "Survey Done on Three Restaurants Services" discusses that Black Angus Steakhouse is likely to do better than the other two competitors....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Complaint against the Estate

While the law recognizes the right to palimony for two unmarried individuals who separate, case brief: BARBARA A.... Furthermore, the Estate seeks its own compensation from the plaintiff for unauthorized withdrawals from a home equity line on one of the deceased's residences, removing belongings from one of the residences, and refusing to return stolen financial documents.... Then, in 1995, they supposedly purchase another home together, but the plaintiffs name was taken off the deed for income tax reasons....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

Dying Intestate

In fact, Water's mother and Mathew have given formal indications of taking care of Wes and Warren in case of sudden death of Walter and Jessica.... However, both Mathew and Walter's mom agreed verbally to take care of Wes and Warren.... This case refers to a situation where there is no specific person assigned to take charge of the estate and other property.... In dealing with second case, the Act lays down the procedure followed by relatives with permission to inherit property....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

The Mobile Phone Industry in the UK

(mPhone ltd, n.... From the paper "The Mobile Phone Industry in the UK" it is clear that the attempt to match theory with reality shows that at present there is no single theory that can claim to capture most of the significant or important aspects of the reality represented by the mobile phone industry....
20 Pages (5000 words) Case Study

Home Care Community Support Contract with in Tameside Social Care

The aim of the paper “home Care Community Support Contract within Tameside Social Care” is to investigate the efficiency, effectiveness, and quality of an existing external contract within the Learning Disability Service at Tameside Metropolitan borough Council.... The existing contract for Tameside social and health care for persons with learning disabilities appears to be costlier and less efficient as far as the quality of the service offered to the patients....
23 Pages (5750 words) Case Study

Analysis of the Criminal Law Case

The author of the paper titled "Analysis of the Criminal Law case" assesses the liability of each of the parties in the case of serious crime and looks at causation and discusses whether that chain of causation has been broken by intervening events.... A similar case that might assist the courts in reaching their decision in R v Fitzgerald9.... In this case, the defendant drove off in an attempt to escape the police.... Another case which had similar facts to the aforementioned one in Ferguson v HM Advocate10....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Australian Law Case

From this work, it is clear that Malcolm can claim damages for fraudulent representation made by Georgia in respect to her high standard of maintenance in her pet care firm.... This work "Australian Law case" describes Malcolm and his trip to Georgia.... owever, in our case, Exclusion clauses will not come to the rescue of Georgia since the valuable tropical fish died due to her negligence in feeding them....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Leading a Team of Care Home Professionals

This case study “Leading a Team of Care home Professionals” is a reflection and practical comparison of author's own experience as a professional home care provider and the contemporary leadership theories.... A more scientific and cautious approach is adopted although the explorative nature of home care provider can lead to the diagnosis of an underlying disease resulting in early medical treatment.... In terms of conscientiousness, the leader must train the subordinates to adopt a highly organized approach as opposed to a care-free or easy-going approach....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us