StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Analysis of Death and the Maiden by Dorfman - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Analysis of Death and the Maiden by Dorfman" states that the play is a statement about gender as well as about revenge.  Essentially, in a patriarchal culture, by taking the authority role of the judge, jury, and executioner, Paulina is going against status quo gender role norms.  …
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.6% of users find it useful
Analysis of Death and the Maiden by Dorfman
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis of Death and the Maiden by Dorfman"

DEATH The current report looks at the theme of revenge mixed with the theme of gender roles in the play Death and the Maiden. The basic argument that the current report follows is that Paulina’s actions in the play can be explained as two ways: acts of revenge and acts of an oppressed woman in a patriarchal society; the predominant explanation, however, is that of revenge. This is basically a book that follows the arc of its plot through a revenge theme, so revenge must be the most important element. However, the uncertainty about some of the characters’ relationships also lend this play an air of mystery. Ultimately, Paulina must confront the self-interest that drives her to take violent revenge on Dr. Miranda. Death and the Maiden must be briefly summarized before analysis may proceed. The play is the story of Paulina, who, when in prison for unnamed political crimes, she was raped. All of the actions of revenge and recognition that make up the play’s plot involve this rape. She recognizes the rapist years later, after political fortunes in the country change. The setting of the play is Latin or South America, but the country is not specified. “The time is the present and the place, a country that is probably Chile but could be any country that has given itself a democratic government just after a long period of dictatorship” (Dorfman, 4). The main rapist was a doctor, and Pauline recognizes him later as Dr. Miranda, and takes him captive. The play is left a mystery, however, because Paulina’s husband tries to protect the man, and it is left unsaid whether or not there may be a case of mistaken identity. So, either Pauline is crazy, or she is telling the truth—she gets a confession and appears satisfied, but the ending is left unresolved, so Pauline may kill the doctor It appears at the end of the play that Pauline may have indeed gone crazy, as she starts seeing the doctor’s ghost. Paulina knows superficially that vengeance is an action, not a series of drawn out philosophical uncertainties within the trial she “arranges” for him, but her essential character is motivated by self-interest. This is not to say that Paulina is only interested in self-preservation, but rather that she is unable to simply kill the doctor, as she knows she must, because she is not essentially the sort of person who does not deliberate over decisions in a manner that seeks to instruct others. From this perspective, Paulina is a tragic hero in the play, but her heroism is not forged on the battlefield of the soldier, but rather in the mind of the judge. She must go through a process of rebellion that frees self-interest and philosophizing from her character before he is able to actually act out and carry out her revenge. This process takes up a lot of the play, so that by the end, the viewer or reader is more concerned with Pauline’s self-interest and indecision than they are with the plot of the play, which is being delayed by her failure to simply kill the doctor without having the showy trial. She makes some progress in that she is unable to question the fact that the doctor raped her, but this does not mean that she is willing or ready to act. There are also gender issues that are at work in Paulina’s revenge and trial of the doctor. Women often participate in revolutions, but they seldom bear the fruits of such equality afterwards. Political awareness and advancement like Paulina’s, for a woman was a mixed advancement in many cases, because often when the troops came home, the working women were expected to abandon their roles in the revolution and go back to being a woman in society. Although women were taking more jobs than ever in the 20th century worldwide, gender segregation remained a major issue in South and Latin America, where most countries have strong patriarchal cultures. Income disparities between women and men working the same job continued as proof of continuing sex discrimination, even though women became more respected because of what they had achieved during various revolutions. Dr Miranda often shows more direct action than Paulina when he is being put to the show trial, and when he realizes that she represents a danger. When revenge does come, it comes too late, and tragedy ensues. Paulina has spent most of the play deliberating in the show trial about her revenge on the doctor, so that in the end, the action appears less important than the deliberation, and the play’s viewer or reader is left with the mystery. This is a direct challenge to the cultural values of the play’s contemporary audience, who were taught to respect knowledge and the method of the linear narrative with a clear ending. What the playwright seems to be saying is that something like a show trial for human rights abuses actually impediments to getting things done as they are supposed to be done. They can provide keen insights into the human mind and spirit, but ultimately, they are only based in the realm of the mind and the spirit, and therefore have trouble assimilating into reality. Paulina is often both distracted and abstracted in her relation to other characters in speech and the audience. She offers keen and often startling accusations during the trial, such as the torture by electricity, that work to blind the audience or reader to what is really happening: time is slipping past, and no action is being taken. It would not be stretching the truth to say that throughout most of the play, the key way that Paulina seeks revenge against Dr. Miranda is in her own mind. She does this because she is used to following her own self-interest and has trouble assimilating her own self into reality. As mentioned above, this play is a statement about gender as well as about revenge. Essentially, in a patriarchal culture, by taking the authority role of the judge, jury, and executioner, Paulina is going against status quo gender role norms. She is showing a feminist response indicative of Latin American women and the struggles they have faced in a patriarchal culture. Especially when this culture is then used to suppress native cultures, as in Latin and South America, this patriarchal culture often has preconceived notions of superiority and ideas of backwardness, which are evidenced in the European colonialist’s fear of slipping into a pre-industrial state in which nature is left uncontrolled. The play shows how there have been many progressive strides made in the women’s liberation movement worldwide in the past forty years, with women taking some of the same roles as men. Different nations and cultures have different estimations of this progress within different structures. A lot has changed during the twentieth century, and great strides have been made in terms of equality and liberation. One of the main strides that has occurred more recently within the women’s liberation movement is a shift in emphasis from women’s liberation as it is perceived in a mode that stresses middle-class economics to a more socially concerned paradigm of liberation that unites the rich and poor in their struggle. And although class and economics are interesting to apply to Death and the Maiden, as well as feminism, it is mainly less a play about gender than it is about revenge. Paulina’s revenge, and her delay through the show trial, are the points of the play’s key focus. REFERENCE Dorfman, A (2000). Death and the Maiden. New York: G rove. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Analysis of Death and the Maiden by Dorfman Book Report/Review, n.d.)
Analysis of Death and the Maiden by Dorfman Book Report/Review. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1560807-death-and-the-maiden-book-review
(Analysis of Death and the Maiden by Dorfman Book Report/Review)
Analysis of Death and the Maiden by Dorfman Book Report/Review. https://studentshare.org/literature/1560807-death-and-the-maiden-book-review.
“Analysis of Death and the Maiden by Dorfman Book Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1560807-death-and-the-maiden-book-review.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of Death and the Maiden by Dorfman

Emotions and Ethics: A Case of Contention Regarding Paulina

Emotions and Ethics: A Case of Contention regarding Paulina [Name of Student] [Name of Instructor] [Name of Course] [Date] Emotions and Ethics: A Case of Contention regarding Paulina Paulina, the protagonist of death and the maiden has been noted as a character who requires emotional attachment from the audiences as she was raped and torture as she was jailed by the military officials for her conduct of activism.... The story The death and the maiden put the audiences in the agreement and disagreement of the contention that the emotional stance of the story where Paulina needs justice brings us closer to her and feel sympathetic for her experience....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Margaret Atwood's Death by Landscape & A buldingsroman

Prior to this experience, Laura knows nothing of death.... English Literature: Margaret Atwood's “death by Landscape” and Katherine Mansfield's “The Garden Party” (Name) (University) English Literature: Margaret Atwood's “death by Landscape” and Katherine Mansfield's “The Garden Party” I.... Atwood's “death by Landscape” is a story about Lois, an old woman who reminisces her earlier years.... English Literature: Margaret Atwood's “death by Landscape” and Katherine Mansfield's “The Garden Party” English Literature: Margaret Atwood's “death by Landscape” and Katherine Mansfield's “The Garden Party” I....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Paulina Salinas and Noboru Kuroda

Yukio Mishima's novel, The Sailor Who Fell From Grace With The Sea, and Ariel Dorfman's death and the maiden are two powerful and provocative stories that makes the audience contemplate on the meaning of being human with focus on the workings of the mind.... His works include death and the maiden, The Late Song of Manuel Sendero and My House is on Fire.... The unique story in the death and the maiden was the result of Dorfman's fascination of the process of the Rettig Commission, a commission established by the democratically elected president Patricio Aylwin to investigate the crimes of the dictatorship that had ended in death or the presumption of death....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review

Comparative Literacy

hellip; It can be considered that literary works such as Ariel dorfman's The Death of a Maiden and Athol Fugard's Sizwe Bansi are Dead had encountered similar hindrances as their own characters.... The paper "Comparative Literacy" presents the main objective of the study undertaken is to be able to present important issues that been discussed and tackled by different literary works....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Writing the Self in China

This paper "Writing the Self in China" focuses on the fact that Lisa Rofel (2007) and Judith Farquhar (2007) are among some of the scholars who have researched this issue of “Writing the Self”.... When I went visiting China, I experienced this phenomenon of writing the self.... nbsp;… Particularly in my year abroad in Guangzhou, my Chinese girlfriend and I were passing through a very traumatic period in our relationship....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Paulina Salinas and Noboru Kuroda: A Comparative Analysis

"Paulina Salinas and Noboru Kuroda: A Comparative Analysis" paper compares Yukio Mishima's novel, The Sailor Who Fell From Grace With The Sea, and Ariel Dorfman's death and the maiden, two powerful and provocative stories that make the audience contemplate on the meaning of being human.... However, one will notice that there are similarities between Paulina Salas of dorfman and Noburo Kuroda of Mishima's story.... he interest of this aim of this paper is to analyze not only the perceived similarities but also the differences in the way Mishima and dorfman introduce and develop the characters that I have just mentioned....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

The Concept of Marketing Commodities in a Consumer Market

The paper 'The Concept of Marketing Commodities in a Consumer Market' presents the inherently weak moral imperative of capitalist culture that makes this outcome inevitable.... Across the world, more so in advanced societies, marketing strategies have attracted much flak.... nbsp;… The United Kingdom is no exception to this rule as well....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Sociological Perspectives on the Death Penalty

The paper "Sociological Perspectives on the death Penalty" discusses that everyday life is compared to the theatre that relies on the structure of social settings, rules and expectations.... hellip; The position of structural functionalism on the death penalty can, therefore, be interpreted in opposing directions.... On one hand, the death penalty is viewed as an instrument for promoting social cohesion, while on the other, it is said to reflect the inherent institutionalized violence in the society in which it is given sanction or practised....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us