StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Utilitarian Thought of Philosophy - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
This assignment "The Utilitarian Thought of Philosophy" critically evaluates the utilitarian position that an action is right, if and only if it maximizes the greatest good for the greatest number. Mill explained that Rule Utilitarianism was the rule that worked towards maximizing happiness…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
The Utilitarian Thought of Philosophy
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Utilitarian Thought of Philosophy"

Question: Critically evaluate the utilitarian position that an action is right, if and only if it maximizes the greatest good for the greatest number. Are the arguments used to support this position successful? Why or why not? Answer: The utilitarian thought of philosophy supports the view that an action is considered to be correct if the action brings about happiness of the greatest number of people. John Stuart Mill was a philosopher of the utilitarian idea and claimed that Rule Utilitarianism is the rule for leading a proper and a moral life. Mill explained that Rule Utilitarianism was the rule that worked towards maximizing happiness. According to this rule an act is moral and correct if it brings about happiness for the maximum number of people. In the same way it puts an action to be morally incorrect if it brings about unhappiness and is the cause of displeasure for the maximum number of people. Mill explained this rule with the aid of the principle of utility. According to this principle which is also sometimes referred to as the principle of happiness, for a person to be happy himself he should consider the happiness of others to be as important as his own happiness. This philosophy of happiness was further explained by John Stuart Mill with the assistance of his theories by putting forward the rules of thumb. The reason for presenting these rules was that Mill argued that a person should not misunderstand the meaning of happiness. These rules were used by him to support the theory of maximizing happiness and provide an insight into the meaning of this principle. These rules encompass the aspects of this principle to cover the features and the characteristics which should be understood about it. The rules of thumb were to be always considered to reach to a proper conclusion as to what happiness actually is. According to these rules, it is through knowledge and learning that a person actually gets to know that what act will bring about the maximum happiness. The reason behind this is that it is through awareness of the developing of humans and human nature that one can understand that what act is morally correct and will actually bring about the maximum happiness for the maximum number of people. These rules also present that a person should increase his level when thinking about happiness. That is happiness should not be restricted to certain things. A person should search for happiness in everything that surrounds him. These things can range from nature to music to history and art. That is a person should be learned and it is through his knowledge that he will be able to find happiness in all these things. To make his theory even better understood Mill clearly presented the exceptions that implied to this rule of happiness. He explained that though acts like lying and murder are considered to be wrong under normal circumstances but these acts become acceptable under certain conditions. An example to this can be that when a person has to protect himself from a murderer he has a right to act in self defense. Another example which can be considered is a person can lie when the person has to conceal some information from someone who might misuse it and cause great harm. According to the utilitarian position, it is the consequences of an act that matter the most. In this regard, John Stuart Mill who was a utilitarian also talked about the results of the actions that a person performed. According to Mill, most of the actions that human beings perform are out of self interest. He explained that if a person performed an act for others but with some self interest and the result is a good one then that act is morally praiseworthy. If one saves a drowning fellow creature with the intention that he would be paid for it is not wrong. This is because according to Mill the result of the act that a person is performing is good and brings about happiness. According to Mill an act is morally praiseworthy if it brings about the maximum happiness. Obviously letting the person drown would bring no happiness at all. As this act has given a good end result with happiness, Mill considered it to be morally praiseworthy. Thus the utilitarian position argues very strongly in favor of the concept of the maximum happiness. This principle of happiness is considered correct irrespective of the fact that the act that whether the action is performed out of a pure intention and motive of helping someone or whether the act is performed for personal interest. That is the utilitarianism considers an act which brings about the maximum happiness even if the person who performed this act did not do it with the intention of doing something good. The utilitarian concept explains that the key to leading a moral life is the consideration of the benefit of the maximum people. This concept explains that proper education and learning can teach a person that which acts will bring about happiness. This is because it is through experience and learning that a person knows how this world has evolved and what acts are moral and will be good for the maximum number of people. The arguments that are used to support this position are convincing but there are reasons which provide an insight into the flaws that have been overlooked by the utilitarian position. During the reign of Hitler in Germany, experimental work was conducted on the Jewish slaves. The purpose of these experiments was to learn about the pathological conditions that affected humans so that the life quality and expectancy of the human beings could be improved. These experiments provided the ground for many discoveries and many things were learned from them but many detainees on whom these experiments were performed lost their lives in the process. The purpose of these experiments was to serve humanity and they did work towards bringing about the benefit of the maximum number of people by improving their lives as well as the lives of the future generations. But this benefit was obtained at the stake of the lives of poor prisoners. The utilitarian principle argues in favor of the thought of bringing out the maximum happiness and thus following the rule, this unethical practice would be considered to be correct considering the fact that the result of this experiment was beneficial and was leading to the process of maximizing happiness. Another example that can be considered to show the flaws of this position of a utilitarian is that of embryonic stem cell research. This research can be used for the curing of many diseases like cancer, Parkinson’s disease, multiple sclerosis and other pathological conditions. Secondly with the help of this research the process of human development can be properly understood. though this research has a very good scope and it could be helpful in saving many lives, this research has not yet obtained any cure or remedy and above this research leads to the death of a life and thus the killing of one for saving others. If the embryonic stem cell research is considered from the utilitarian perspective, this research should be promoted because it allows the treatment of many diseases and is helpful for the human beings. But when it is considered from an ethical point of view, many questions arise because it involves the destroying of a human embryo which has the potential to become a normal human being. Thus it is similar to killing a human being which is in the process of growth. Just in a few weeks the heart of the embryo starts to beat and it would be a very harsh act to kill a being. The embryos which are being worked upon are provided by parents by themselves who are in favor of this research. After these embryos become short the ovum would be obtained from women putting them at health risks. Thus again for saving another being the life of one may be put at stake. It can thus be explained that the arguments provided by the utilitarian position are not successful and incorporation of a higher consideration and explanation regarding this principle is required to make this position of utilitarianism completely supportable and free of flaws. References: Top of Form Mill, J. S., & Sher, G. (2001). Utilitarianism. Indianapolis: Hackett Pub. Top of Form Schaefer N. (2004). The legacy of Nazi medicine. New Atlantis (Washington, D.C.). 5, 54-60. Top of Form Stewart, D., & Blocker, H. G. (2005). Fundamentals of philosophy. Upper Saddle River, N.J.: Prentice-Hall. Bottom of Form Bottom of Form Bottom of Form Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Utilitarian Thought of Philosophy Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
The Utilitarian Thought of Philosophy Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1735308-philosophy-utilitarianism
(The Utilitarian Thought of Philosophy Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
The Utilitarian Thought of Philosophy Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1735308-philosophy-utilitarianism.
“The Utilitarian Thought of Philosophy Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1735308-philosophy-utilitarianism.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Utilitarian Thought of Philosophy

International Business Ethics

If it was demonstrated that the action was more pleasurable than painful then it was in keeping with the utilitarian philosophy and the action should be undertaken.... hellip; The ancient Greeks had a moral ideal of seriousness, which could be expressed in religious, philosophical, or ethical activity, but not so easily in physical production; early modern thinkers, however, recognize a virtue of industriousness, which tend to be expressed in activity related to production, to subduing the physical environment" (Garrett p1). Virtue ethics is a philosophy that de-emphasizes rules and concentrates its focus on the 'nature' of the person acting....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Utilitarianism as a Public Philosophy

the utilitarian's view is in contrary to the Kant's principle of duty since the main focus of Kant's principle is to achieve a goal through actions and means that are in accordance to the duty to moral principles and guidelines.... This paper "Utilitarianism as a Public philosophy" focuses on the fact that utilitarianism is a philosophy in application to a different field which is mainly based on the utility of the thoughts.... It is a philosophy based on the resulting event on the basis of the application of the concept....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The War's Ethical Nature According to Utilitarian Ethics

That means that to the utilitarian philosopher the wars ethical nature is also up for debate still.... The usefulness of such an ethical philosophy when dealing with acts of war should be obvious.... One popular way of summing up the philosophy is whatever does the greatest good for the greatest number of people.... One popular way of summing up the philosophy is whatever does the greatest good for the greatest number of people....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

The Use of a Utilitarian Philosophy

Utilitarian philosophy as a checkmate or balancing system for putting Business Organizations in the right perspectives about their legal, social, economic and moral obligations as far as consumers' rights and well-being are concerned.... Utilitarian philosophy or Utilitarianism can be described as a mechanism by which happiness and satisfaction in life could be made available to all people without prejudicial consideration or discrimination (Goodin, 1995).... Goodin (1995) strongly believed that Utilitarianism is a public philosophy whereby governments make laws and regulations to control the activities of all producers of goods and services within the country in a way that they will not jeopardize the well-being and state of happiness of the consumers....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

What is Happiness

The Utilitarian Thought of Philosophy supports the Thus the utilitarian position argues very strongly in favor of the concept of the maximum happiness.... the utilitarian concept explains that the key to leading a moral life is the consideration of the benefit of the maximum people.... The arguments that are used to support this position are convincing but there are reasons which provide an insight into the flaws that have been overlooked by the utilitarian position....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Three Takes on Ethics

This kind of philosophy reminds me of occasions when, as a child, I would behave in a certain way (eating my vegetables, for instance) out of an obligation without necessarily agreeing with that action.... The author of this essay claims that Western philosophy has a rich history of ethical thought dating all the way back to the days of Plato and Aristotle.... Each ethical philosophy differs in what it values, what it thinks should dictate actions, where the locus of control for forming a moral code rests and so on....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Philosophy: The Concept of Utilitarism

But it forms only one part in the big world of philosophy and science.... The supporters of the theory say the utilitarian principle is the only moral criterion of human acts, and this principle is to ensure that we should always seek to maximize the predominance of good over evil.... Although firstly the suppositions of utilitarianism appear in the writings of the British moralists of XVI-XVII centuries, the modern theory of the… ept is most often associated with the British philosopher John Stuart Mill (1806- 1873) who elaborated the theory from a hedonistic version proposed by his mentor Jeremy Bentham (1748- 1832) who thought a person should experience a lot of pleasure and avoid suffering....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Patients Confidential Disclosures through the Lenses of Kantian Philosophy

nbsp;Different schools of philosophy have come out with different theories on what is moral or ethical and what is not.... The paper "Patients Confidential Disclosures through the Lenses of Kantian philosophy" explores moral dilemma of whether to do a certain thing or not.... Another school of thought called the Utilitarianism was advocated by John Stuart Mill in the eighteenth century.... Both these schools of thought seem to be opposing each other, as they encourage different ways of looking at things....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us